Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana.
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Hum Factors. 2018 Jun;60(4):445-464. doi: 10.1177/0018720818759102. Epub 2018 Feb 22.
Objective This research sought to determine whether people can perceive and process three nonredundant (and unrelated) signals in vision, hearing, and touch at the same time and how aging and concurrent task demands affect this ability. Background Multimodal displays have been shown to improve multitasking and attention management; however, their potential limitations are not well understood. The majority of studies on multimodal information presentation have focused on the processing of only two concurrent and, most often, redundant cues by younger participants. Method Two experiments were conducted in which younger and older adults detected and responded to a series of singles, pairs, and triplets of visual, auditory, and tactile cues in the absence (Experiment 1) and presence (Experiment 2) of an ongoing simulated driving task. Detection rates, response times, and driving task performance were measured. Results Compared to younger participants, older adults showed longer response times and higher error rates in response to cues/cue combinations. Older participants often missed the tactile cue when three cues were combined. They sometimes falsely reported the presence of a visual cue when presented with a pair of auditory and tactile signals. Driving performance suffered most in the presence of cue triplets. Conclusion People are more likely to miss information if more than two concurrent nonredundant signals are presented to different sensory channels. Application The findings from this work help inform the design of multimodal displays and ensure their usefulness across different age groups and in various application domains.
目的 本研究旨在确定人们是否能够同时感知和处理视觉、听觉和触觉中的三个非冗余(且不相关)信号,以及衰老和并发任务需求如何影响这种能力。 背景 多模态显示已被证明可以提高多任务处理和注意力管理能力;然而,其潜在限制尚不清楚。大多数关于多模态信息呈现的研究都集中在处理仅两个同时出现的、且通常是冗余的提示,且这些研究的参与者通常是年轻人。 方法 进行了两项实验,其中年轻和年长的成年人在没有(实验 1)和存在(实验 2)持续模拟驾驶任务的情况下,检测和响应一系列视觉、听觉和触觉的单个、成对和三个信号。测量了检测率、响应时间和驾驶任务表现。 结果 与年轻参与者相比,年长参与者在响应提示/提示组合时的响应时间更长,错误率更高。年长参与者在三个提示组合时经常会错过触觉提示。他们有时会在呈现一对听觉和触觉信号时错误地报告视觉提示的存在。在存在提示三元组的情况下,驾驶性能受到的影响最大。 结论 如果向不同的感觉通道呈现超过两个同时的非冗余信号,人们更有可能错过信息。 应用 这项工作的发现有助于为多模态显示器的设计提供信息,并确保它们在不同年龄组和各种应用领域的有用性。