Radcliff Elizabeth, Crouch Elizabeth, Strompolis Melissa
South Carolina Rural Health Research Center, Arnold School of Public Health, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA
Children's Trust of South Carolina, Columbia, USA
Rural Remote Health. 2018 Feb;18(1):4434. doi: 10.22605/RRH4434. Epub 2018 Feb 21.
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are traumatic events that occur in a child's life between birth and 18 years. Exposure to one or more ACE has been linked to participation in risky health behaviors and the experience of chronic health conditions in adulthood. The risk for poor outcomes increases as the number of ACEs experienced increases. This research investigates rural-urban differences in exposure to ACEs using a sample from a representative southern US state, South Carolina.
Using data from the 2014-2015 South Carolina Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) and residential rurality based on UICs, ACE exposure among South Carolina adults was tabulated by urban versus rural residence and selected other demographic characteristics. Using standard descriptive statistics, frequencies and proportions were calculated for each categorical variable. Multivariable regression modeling was used to examine the impact of residential rurality and selected sociodemographic characteristics on overall and specific types of ACE exposure. All analyses used survey sampling weights that accounted for the BRFSS sampling strategy.
The analytic sample of 18 176 respondents comprised 15.9% rural residents. Top reported ACEs for both rural and urban residents were the same: parental divorce/separation, emotional abuse, and household substance use. Compared to urban residents, a higher proportion of rural respondents reported experiencing no ACEs (41.4% vs 38.3%, p<0.01). The prevalence of four or more ACEs in rural respondents was 15.0%; in comparison, 17.6% of urban respondents had four or more ACEs (p<0.01). In logistic regression predicting exposure to four or more ACEs and adjusting for sex, age, race/ethnicity, education, and income, rural respondents were less likely than urban respondents to report four or more ACEs (adjusted odds ratio 0.75, 95% confidence interval 0.74-0.75).
Despite reporting less ACE exposure than urban counterparts, almost 60% of rural residents reported at least one ACE and 15% reported experiencing four or more ACEs. In contrast to urban residents, rural residents may experience more social connections within their families and communities, which may influence ACE exposure; however, care coordination, social support services, and access to health care are limited in rural areas. Thus, families in rural areas may be less equipped to mitigate and manage the effects of ACEs. Findings from this study thus suggest that interventions to prevent ACE exposure are just as needed in rural southern communities as they are in urban southern communities. Topics important for future research could include an examination of ACEs in rural communities in terms of individuals' health outcomes and their access to health care, as well as the role of protective factors. Programs and policies that assist in ACE prevention in rural areas are important to reducing these multigenerational threats to health and wellbeing.
儿童期不良经历(ACEs)是指儿童出生至18岁期间生活中发生的创伤性事件。接触一种或多种ACEs与参与危险健康行为以及成年后患慢性健康状况有关。随着经历的ACEs数量增加,出现不良后果的风险也会增加。本研究使用美国南部代表性州南卡罗来纳州的样本,调查城乡在接触ACEs方面的差异。
利用2014 - 2015年南卡罗来纳州行为风险因素监测系统(BRFSS)的数据以及基于城市影响代码(UICs)的居住农村性,按城乡居住情况和选定的其他人口特征对南卡罗来纳州成年人的ACEs暴露情况进行列表统计。使用标准描述性统计方法,计算每个分类变量的频率和比例。采用多变量回归模型来检验居住农村性和选定的社会人口特征对总体和特定类型ACEs暴露的影响。所有分析都使用了考虑BRFSS抽样策略的调查抽样权重。
18176名受访者的分析样本中,农村居民占15.9%。农村和城市居民报告最多的ACEs相同:父母离婚/分居、情感虐待和家庭物质使用。与城市居民相比,更高比例的农村受访者报告未经历任何ACEs(41.4%对38.3%,p<0.01)。农村受访者中经历四种或更多ACEs的患病率为15.0%;相比之下,17.6%的城市受访者有四种或更多ACEs(p<0.01)。在预测接触四种或更多ACEs并对性别、年龄、种族/族裔、教育程度和收入进行调整的逻辑回归分析中,农村受访者报告四种或更多ACEs的可能性低于城市受访者(调整后的优势比为0.75,95%置信区间为0.74 - 0.75)。
尽管农村居民报告的ACEs暴露比城市居民少,但近60% 的农村居民报告至少经历过一次ACEs,15% 报告经历过四种或更多ACEs。与城市居民不同,农村居民可能在其家庭和社区中体验到更多的社会联系,这可能会影响ACEs暴露;然而,农村地区的医疗协调、社会支持服务和医疗保健获取有限。因此,农村地区的家庭可能在减轻和管理ACEs影响方面能力较弱。本研究结果表明,美国南部农村社区与城市社区一样,同样需要预防ACEs暴露的干预措施。未来研究的重要主题可能包括根据个人健康结果及其获得医疗保健的情况,对农村社区的ACEs进行研究,以及保护因素的作用。有助于农村地区预防ACEs的项目和政策对于减少这些对健康和幸福的多代威胁至关重要。