Truong Perrine, Millet Gregoire P, Gojanovic Boris
University of Lausanne, Faculty of Biology and Medicine, Lausanne, Switzerland.
University of Lausanne, Institute of Sport Sciences ISSUL, Faculty of Biology and Medicine, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Int J Sports Med. 2018 Apr;39(4):304-313. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-122741. Epub 2018 Feb 23.
This study aimed to investigate the differences in maximal oxygen uptake (V̇O) and submaximal thresholds between a standard graded exercise test (GXT) and a perceptually regulated graded exercise test (PRGXT) in trained runners. Eleven well-trained middle- to long-distance runners performed both tests in a randomized order. PRGXT used incremental "clamps" of rating of perceived exertion (RPE) over 10×1-min stages on an automated treadmill equipped with a sonar sensor allowing them to change their running speed instantly and in a natural way. GXT used fixed 1 kmh increment every minute. Ventilatory threshold (VT) and respiratory compensation point (RCP) were determined using ventilatory equivalents. No differences were found in V̇O (68.0 (5.3) vs. 69.5 (5.9) ml·min·kg, p=0.243), minute ventilation (V̇E) (159.4 (35.0) vs. 162.4 (33.7) l·min, p=0.175), heart rate (HR) (188.4 (6.9) vs. 190.7 (5.2) bpm, p=0.254) and speed (21.0 (1.7) vs. 21.1 (2.3) km·h-, p=0.761) between GXT and PRGXT. At VT, there were no significant differences between GXT and PRGXT for any outcome variables. For 8 of 11 subjects, it was not possible to determine RCP from ventilatory equivalent in PRGXT. GXT appears more relevant for a comprehensive gas analysis in trained runners.
本研究旨在调查训练有素的跑步者在标准分级运动试验(GXT)和感知调节分级运动试验(PRGXT)之间最大摄氧量(V̇O)和次最大阈值的差异。11名训练有素的中长跑运动员以随机顺序进行了这两项测试。PRGXT在配备声纳传感器的自动跑步机上,通过在10个1分钟阶段内对主观用力程度(RPE)进行递增“钳制”,使他们能够以自然的方式即时改变跑步速度。GXT每分钟固定递增1公里/小时。使用通气当量确定通气阈值(VT)和呼吸补偿点(RCP)。在GXT和PRGXT之间,V̇O(68.0(5.3)对69.5(5.9)ml·min·kg,p = 0.243)、分钟通气量(V̇E)(159.4(35.0)对162.4(33.7)l·min,p = 0.175)、心率(HR)(188.4(6.9)对190.7(5.2)bpm,p = 0.254)和速度(21.0(1.7)对21.1(2.3)km·h-,p = 0.761)均未发现差异。在VT时,GXT和PRGXT之间的任何结果变量均无显著差异。对于11名受试者中的8名,无法从PRGXT的通气当量中确定RCP。GXT似乎更适用于对训练有素的跑步者进行全面的气体分析。