Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University at Buffalo, SUNY, Buffalo, NY, 14260, USA.
Applied Technology Laboratory for Advanced Surgery (ATLAS), Roswell Park Cancer Institute, Buffalo, NY, 14263, USA.
Sci Rep. 2018 Feb 26;8(1):3667. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-22025-1.
Mutual trust is important in surgical teams, especially in robot-assisted surgery (RAS) where interaction with robot-assisted interface increases the complexity of relationships within the surgical team. However, evaluation of trust between surgeons is challenging and generally based on subjective measures. Mentor-Trainee trust was defined as assessment of mentor on trainee's performance quality and approving trainee's ability to continue performing the surgery. Here, we proposed a novel method of objectively assessing mentor-trainee trust during RAS based on patterns of brain activity of surgical mentor observing trainees. We monitored the EEG activity of a mentor surgeon while he observed procedures performed by surgical trainees and quantified the mentor's brain activity using functional and cognitive brain state features. We used methods from machine learning classification to identity key features that distinguish trustworthiness from concerning performances. Results showed that during simple surgical task, functional brain features are sufficient to classify trust. While, during more complex tasks, the addition of cognitive features could provide additional accuracy, but functional brain state features drive classification performance. These results indicate that functional brain network interactions hold information that may help objective trainee specific mentorship and aid in laying the foundation of automation in the human-robot shared control environment during RAS.
在外科手术团队中,相互信任很重要,特别是在机器人辅助手术(RAS)中,因为与机器人辅助界面的交互增加了手术团队内部关系的复杂性。然而,评估外科医生之间的信任是具有挑战性的,并且通常基于主观措施。导师-学员信任被定义为评估导师对学员表现质量的评估,并认可学员继续进行手术的能力。在这里,我们提出了一种基于观察学员的手术导师脑活动模式来客观评估 RAS 期间导师-学员信任的新方法。我们监测了一名导师外科医生的脑电图活动,同时他观察了外科学员进行的手术,并使用功能和认知脑状态特征来量化导师的大脑活动。我们使用机器学习分类方法来识别区分可信赖性和令人担忧的表现的关键特征。结果表明,在简单的手术任务中,功能脑特征足以进行分类信任。而在更复杂的任务中,添加认知特征可以提供额外的准确性,但功能脑状态特征驱动分类性能。这些结果表明,功能脑网络相互作用包含有助于客观学员特定指导的信息,并有助于为 RAS 期间人机共享控制环境中的自动化奠定基础。