Koo Yu-Chin, Chang Jung-Su, Chen Yi Chun
School of Nutrition and Health Science, Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan.
PLoS One. 2018 Feb 28;13(2):e0191982. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0191982. eCollection 2018.
Composition claim, nutrition claim and health claim are often found on the commercial complementary food packaging. The introduction of complementary foods (CFs) to infants is a turning point in the development of their eating behavior, and their commercial use for Taiwanese infants is growing. In Taiwan, lots of the advertisements for CFs employed health or nutrition claims to promote the products, but the actual nutritional content of these CFs is not clear. The aim of this study was to compare the food claims of commercial complementary food products with their actual nutrition facts. A sample of 363 commercial CFs was collected from websites, local supermarkets, and other food stores, and their nutrition-related claims were classified into composition, nutrition, and health categories. Although the World Health Organization recommends that infants should be exclusively breastfed for the first 6 months, 48.2% of the commercial CFs were targeted at infants younger than 6 months. Therefore, marketing regulations should be implemented to curb early weaning as a result of products targeted at infants younger than 6 months. More than 50% of Taiwanese commercial CFs have high sugar content and more than 20% were high in sodium. Products with health claims, such as "provides good nutrition to children" or "improves appetite," have higher sodium or sugar content than do those without such claims. Moreover, products with calcium or iron content claims did not contain more calcium or iron than products without such claims. Additionally, a significantly greater proportion of the products with "no added sugar" claims were classified as having high sugar content as compared to those without such claims. Parents cannot choose the healthiest food products for their children by simply focusing on food claims. Government should regulate the labeling of nutrition facts and food claims for foods targeted at infants younger than 12 months.
成分声明、营养声明和健康声明在商业辅食包装上屡见不鲜。给婴儿引入辅食是其饮食行为发展的一个转折点,并且在台湾,辅食在商业上对婴儿的使用正在增加。在台湾,许多辅食广告利用健康或营养声明来推销产品,但这些辅食的实际营养成分并不明确。本研究的目的是比较商业辅食产品的食品声明与其实际营养成分。从网站、当地超市和其他食品店收集了363种商业辅食样本,并将其与营养相关的声明分为成分、营养和健康类别。尽管世界卫生组织建议婴儿在出生后的前6个月应纯母乳喂养,但48.2%的商业辅食针对的是6个月以下的婴儿。因此,应实施营销法规,以遏制因针对6个月以下婴儿的产品导致的过早断奶现象。超过50%的台湾商业辅食含糖量高,超过20%的钠含量高。带有“为儿童提供良好营养”或“增进食欲”等健康声明的产品,其钠或糖含量高于没有此类声明的产品。此外,声称含有钙或铁的产品,其钙或铁含量并不比没有此类声明的产品高。此外,与没有“不添加糖”声明的产品相比,声称“不添加糖”的产品中被归类为含糖量高的比例显著更高。家长不能仅仅通过关注食品声明就为孩子选择最健康的食品。政府应规范针对12个月以下婴儿的食品的营养成分标签和食品声明。