Clauset Aaron
Department of Computer Science, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309, USA. BioFrontiers Institute, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80303, USA. Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, NM 87501, USA.
Sci Adv. 2018 Feb 21;4(2):eaao3580. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aao3580. eCollection 2018 Feb.
Since 1945, there have been relatively few large interstate wars, especially compared to the preceding 30 years, which included both World Wars. This pattern, sometimes called the long peace, is highly controversial. Does it represent an enduring trend caused by a genuine change in the underlying conflict-generating processes? Or is it consistent with a highly variable but otherwise stable system of conflict? Using the empirical distributions of interstate war sizes and onset times from 1823 to 2003, we parameterize stationary models of conflict generation that can distinguish trends from statistical fluctuations in the statistics of war. These models indicate that both the long peace and the period of great violence that preceded it are not statistically uncommon patterns in realistic but stationary conflict time series. This fact does not detract from the importance of the long peace or the proposed mechanisms that explain it. However, the models indicate that the postwar pattern of peace would need to endure at least another 100 to 140 years to become a statistically significant trend. This fact places an implicit upper bound on the magnitude of any change in the true likelihood of a large war after the end of the Second World War. The historical patterns of war thus seem to imply that the long peace may be substantially more fragile than proponents believe, despite recent efforts to identify mechanisms that reduce the likelihood of interstate wars.
自1945年以来,大规模的跨州战争相对较少,尤其是与之前包括两次世界大战的30年相比。这种模式,有时被称为长期和平,极具争议性。它是代表了由潜在冲突产生过程的真正变化所导致的持久趋势吗?还是与一个高度可变但其他方面稳定的冲突体系相一致?利用1823年至2003年跨州战争规模和爆发时间的经验分布,我们对冲突产生的平稳模型进行参数化,该模型可以区分战争统计中的趋势与统计波动。这些模型表明,长期和平及其之前的暴力时期在现实但平稳的冲突时间序列中并非统计上罕见的模式。这一事实并不减损长期和平或解释它的提议机制的重要性。然而,模型表明,战后的和平模式至少还需要持续100到140年才能成为具有统计显著性的趋势。这一事实对第二次世界大战结束后大规模战争真正可能性的任何变化幅度隐含了一个上限。因此,战争的历史模式似乎意味着,尽管最近有人努力找出降低跨州战争可能性的机制,但长期和平可能比支持者认为的要脆弱得多。