Pierrefeu-Lagrange Anne-Claire, Mari Karine, Hoss Caroline, Cullen Breda, Nisbet Lorraine
Plastic Reconstructive and Aesthetic Plastic Surgeon, Lyon, France.
Health Economics and Statistics, RCTs, Lyon, France.
Wounds. 2018 Apr;30(4):84-89. Epub 2018 Jan 26.
Dressings are a mainstay for wound management; however, dressing adherence to the wound or periwound area can cause pain and trauma at removal. Dressing-related trauma includes skin reactions, adherence to the wound, and skin stripping. The development of atraumatic wound contact layer dressings has been a major advancement in reducing trauma.
This study compares the benefits of a cellulose acetate mesh (CAM) coated with soft silicone versus a flexible polyamide net (FPN) coated with soft silicone.
A multicenter, randomized controlled study was conducted in 70 patients (35 in CAM group [1 patient exclused due to not receiving treatment], 35 in the FPN group) with traumatic, postsurgical, and burn wounds. Wounds were assessed once per week for 4 weeks to measure dressing adherence to the wound bed, percent reepithelialization, and patient tolerance. All wounds were prepared according to standard of care wound management protocol at the time of assessment.
In this study, 97.06% (n = 33) of patients in the CAM group and 91.43% (n = 32) in the FPN group did not report dressing adherence during any of the assessments. Average time to complete reepithelialization was 16 days in the CAM group versus 15 days in the FPN group (P = .4958), and both products had excellent tolerance.
This study demonstrated that CAM coated with a soft silicone performed as well as the FPN contact layer in minimizing dressing adherence, time to complete reepithelialization, and patient tolerance.
敷料是伤口处理的主要手段;然而,敷料粘贴在伤口或伤口周围区域在去除时会引起疼痛和创伤。与敷料相关的创伤包括皮肤反应、粘贴在伤口上以及皮肤剥离。无创伤性伤口接触层敷料的开发是减少创伤方面的一项重大进展。
本研究比较了涂有软硅胶的醋酸纤维素网(CAM)与涂有软硅胶的柔性聚酰胺网(FPN)的益处。
对70例患有创伤性、术后和烧伤伤口的患者进行了一项多中心随机对照研究(CAM组35例[1例因未接受治疗而排除],FPN组35例)。每周对伤口进行一次评估,持续4周,以测量敷料对伤口床的粘贴情况、再上皮化百分比和患者耐受性。在评估时,所有伤口均按照护理标准伤口处理方案进行处理。
在本研究中,CAM组97.06%(n = 33)的患者和FPN组91.43%(n = 32)的患者在任何一次评估中均未报告敷料粘贴情况。CAM组完成再上皮化的平均时间为16天,FPN组为15天(P = .4958),两种产品的耐受性均良好。
本研究表明,涂有软硅胶的CAM在减少敷料粘贴、完成再上皮化的时间和患者耐受性方面与FPN接触层表现相当。