Department of Psychiatry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA; Department of Neurology & Ophthalmology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Makerere University School of Medicine, Kampala, Uganda.
Brain Res Bull. 2019 Feb;145:117-128. doi: 10.1016/j.brainresbull.2018.03.002. Epub 2018 Mar 6.
Computerized cognitive rehabilitation training (CCRT) may be beneficial for alleviating persisting neurocognitive deficits in Ugandan severe malaria survivors. We completed a randomized controlled trial of CCRT for both severe malaria and non-malaria cohorts of children.
150 school-age severe malaria and 150 non-malaria children were randomized to three treatment arms: 24 sessions of Captain's Log CCRT for attention, working memory and nonverbal reasoning, in which training on each of 9 tasks difficulty increased with proficiency; a limited CCRT arm that did not titrate to proficiency but randomly cycled across the simplest to moderate level of training; and a passive control arm. Before and after 2 months of CCRT intervention and one year following, children were tested with the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children, 2nd edition (KABC-II), computerized CogState cognitive tests, the Behavior Rating Inventory for Executive Function (BRIEF), and the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL).
Malaria children assigned to the limited-CCRT intervention arm were significantly better than passive controls on KABC-II Mental Processing Index (P = 0.04), Sequential Processing (working memory) (P = 0.02) and the Conceptual Thinking subtest (planning/reasoning) (P = 0.02). At one year post-training, the limited CCRT malaria children had more rapid CogState card detection (attention) (P = 0.02), and improved BRIEF Global Executive Index (P = 0.01) as compared to passive controls. Non-malaria children receiving CCRT significantly benefited only on KABC-II Conceptual Thinking (both full- and limited-CCRT; P < 0.01), CogState Groton maze chase and learning (P < 0.01), and CogState card identification (P = 0.05, full CCRT only). Improvements in KABC-II Conceptual Thinking planning subtest for the non-malaria children persisted to one-year follow-up only for the full-CCRT intervention arm.
For severe malaria survivors, limited CCRT improved attention and memory outcomes more than full CCRT, perhaps because of the greater repetition and practice on relevant training tasks in the absence of the performance titration for full CCRT. There were fewer significant cognitive and behavior benefits for the non-malaria children, with the exception of the planning/reasoning subtest of Conceptual Thinking, with stronger full- compared to limited-CCRT improvements persisting to one-year follow-up.
计算机化认知康复训练(CCRT)可能有助于缓解乌干达重症疟疾幸存者持续存在的神经认知缺陷。我们完成了一项针对重症疟疾和非疟疾儿童队列的 CCRT 随机对照试验。
150 名学龄期重症疟疾儿童和 150 名非疟疾儿童被随机分为三组治疗:24 节 Captain's Log CCRT,用于注意力、工作记忆和非言语推理,其中每个 9 项任务的训练难度随熟练度增加而增加;有限的 CCRT 组,不根据熟练度调整,但随机在最简单到中等训练水平之间循环;以及被动对照组。在 2 个月的 CCRT 干预前后和 1 年后,儿童接受了 Kaufman 儿童评估量表(KABC-II)、计算机化 CogState 认知测试、行为评定量表(BRIEF)和 Achenbach 儿童行为检查表(CBCL)的测试。
接受有限 CCRT 干预的疟疾儿童在 KABC-II 心理处理指数(精神加工指数)(P=0.04)、连续处理(工作记忆)(P=0.02)和概念思维子测试(计划/推理)(P=0.02)上明显优于被动对照组。在训练后 1 年,有限 CCRT 疟疾儿童的 CogState 卡片检测(注意力)(P=0.02)和 BRIEF 全球执行指数(P=0.01)的改善明显优于被动对照组。接受 CCRT 的非疟疾儿童仅在 KABC-II 概念思维(包括完整和有限 CCRT;P<0.01)、CogState 格罗顿迷宫追逐和学习(P<0.01)以及 CogState 卡片识别(P=0.05,仅完整 CCRT)方面有显著获益。非疟疾儿童的 KABC-II 概念思维计划子测试的改善仅在完整 CCRT 干预组持续到 1 年随访。
对于重症疟疾幸存者,有限的 CCRT 比完整的 CCRT 更能改善注意力和记忆力,这可能是因为在没有完整 CCRT 的性能调整的情况下,重复和练习了更多相关的训练任务。非疟疾儿童的认知和行为获益较少,除了概念思维的计划/推理子测试,完整的 CCRT 比有限的 CCRT 改善更显著,且这种改善持续到 1 年随访。