Oshima Toru, Ohtani Maki, Mimasaka Sohtaro
Department of Forensic Sciences, Akita University Graduate School of Medicine, 1-1-1 Hondo, Akita City 010-8543, Japan.
Forensic Sci Int. 2018 May;286:e14-e19. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2018.02.021. Epub 2018 Feb 27.
In recent years, the number of bear attacks has risen in Akita prefecture, Japan. Here, we present the injury patterns of seven fatal bear attacks, and discuss the implication of these findings. We included five cases of Asiatic black bear attacks and two cases of Ezo brown bear attacks. In all cases, the injuries, 2-5 parallel linear lacerations with severe hemorrhaging and decollement, were mainly located on the upper body. These injuries were thought to be fatal as, upon a first encounter, bears often stand and first attack the victim's head and face using their claws. Four lacerations were located at the vertex of the trapezoid in all cases, without severe hemorrhaging on the neck, extremities, or around the antemortem injuries. These injuries were thought to be bite marks incurred by the bears' four large canines, mainly occurring postmortem during the process of predation. These findings differed from those of fatal biting around the neck by other animals such as lions, mountain lions, or large-sized dogs. Further, laceration with avulsion of the skin was found in the inguinal region, without severe hemorrhaging. In some cases, the intestine had been removed from the inguinal injury for predation. In conclusion, the injuries of bear attacks are different from those caused by other animals, owing to the characteristics of bears. By investigating the injuries caused by fatal bear attacks, we can better understand the patterns of such injuries. Especially, the diameter between the canines is sometimes useful to estimate the size and the number of offending bears.
近年来,日本秋田县熊袭击事件的数量有所上升。在此,我们呈现七起致命熊袭击事件的损伤模式,并讨论这些发现的意义。我们纳入了五起亚洲黑熊袭击事件和两起北海道棕熊袭击事件。在所有案例中,损伤表现为2至5条平行的线性撕裂伤,伴有严重出血和皮肤脱套,主要位于上半身。这些损伤被认为是致命的,因为在初次遭遇时,熊常常站立起来,先用爪子攻击受害者的头部和面部。在所有案例中,四条撕裂伤位于梯形顶点处,颈部、四肢或生前损伤周围无严重出血。这些损伤被认为是熊的四颗大型犬齿造成的咬痕,主要发生在死后的捕食过程中。这些发现与狮子、美洲狮或大型犬等其他动物造成的颈部致命咬伤不同。此外,在腹股沟区域发现了伴有皮肤撕脱的撕裂伤,无严重出血。在某些案例中,肠道因捕食从腹股沟损伤处被取出。总之,由于熊的特性,熊袭击造成的损伤与其他动物造成的损伤不同。通过调查致命熊袭击造成的损伤,我们可以更好地了解此类损伤的模式。特别是,犬齿之间的直径有时有助于估计肇事熊的大小和数量。