Almeida Gustavo J, Khoja Samannaaz S, Piva Sara R
Department of Physical Therapy, School of Health and Rehabilitation Science, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Open Access J Sports Med. 2018 Mar 15;9:55-68. doi: 10.2147/OAJSM.S124439. eCollection 2018.
Total joint arthroplasty (TJA) is a common procedure to treat individuals with hip and knee osteoarthritis. While TJAs are successful in decreasing pain and improving quality of life, it is unclear whether individuals who undergo TJA become more physically active after surgery. It is possible that TJA, by itself, is not sufficient to affect the behavior of patients toward physical activity (PA) participation. To increase PA participation, individuals with TJA may need to be exposed to exercise/behavioral interventions specifically aimed to promote PA (ie, in addition to the surgery).
This narrative review aimed to assess the evidence on 1) whether TJAs change PA participation from pre- to postsurgery and 2) whether exercise/behavioral interventions delivered before or after TJA help to promote PA in these patients.
For aim 1, the studies that assessed PA from pre- to post-TJA reported that PA does not change in the first 3 months postsurgery. The results of follow-ups longer than 3 months but shorter than 12 months are contradictory, and the results of follow-ups longer than 12 months provide weak evidence of increased PA. Assessment of changes in PA due to TJA is challenged by the wide variability in demographics, methods used to assess PA, and different pathways of care used across studies. The results for aim 2 were limited by a scarcity of studies that used exercise/behavioral interventions to promote PA.
TJA relieves joint pain and offers a unique opportunity for patients to become more physically active. However, the current evidence is limited and unable to offer definitive results of whether TJA is effective to change PA from pre- to postsurgery. Future large studies in representative samples of patients with TJA are needed to adequately answer this question.
全关节置换术(TJA)是治疗髋膝关节骨关节炎患者的常见手术。虽然全关节置换术在减轻疼痛和改善生活质量方面很成功,但尚不清楚接受全关节置换术的患者术后是否会变得更积极地进行体育活动。全关节置换术本身可能不足以影响患者参与体育活动(PA)的行为。为了增加体育活动的参与度,接受全关节置换术的患者可能需要接受专门旨在促进体育活动的运动/行为干预(即除手术之外)。
本叙述性综述旨在评估以下证据:1)全关节置换术是否会使术前到术后的体育活动参与度发生变化;2)在全关节置换术之前或之后进行的运动/行为干预是否有助于促进这些患者的体育活动。
对于目标1,评估全关节置换术前到术后体育活动的研究报告称,术后前3个月体育活动没有变化。随访时间超过3个月但短于12个月的结果相互矛盾,而随访时间超过12个月的结果提供了体育活动增加的微弱证据。由于人口统计学、评估体育活动的方法以及各研究中使用的不同护理途径存在广泛差异,因此评估全关节置换术导致的体育活动变化面临挑战。目标2的结果受到使用运动/行为干预来促进体育活动的研究稀缺的限制。
全关节置换术可缓解关节疼痛,并为患者提供了变得更积极进行体育活动的独特机会。然而,目前的证据有限,无法提供全关节置换术从术前到术后改变体育活动是否有效的明确结果。需要对全关节置换术患者的代表性样本进行未来的大型研究,以充分回答这个问题。