El-Naggar Hany, Moloney Patrick, Widdess-Walsh Peter, Kilbride Ronan, Delanty Norman, Mullins Gerard
Epilepsy Programme Beaumont Hospital Dublin Ireland.
Royal College of Surgeons Dublin Ireland.
Epilepsia Open. 2017 Sep 1;2(4):467-471. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12071. eCollection 2017 Dec.
Epilepsy and psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) can coexist and may present in two forms: sequential and simultaneous. In sequential presentations, epileptic seizures (ES) are treated and PNES emerge later. Simultaneous recording of ES and PNES by video-electroencephalogram (vEEG) is less well described. We retrospectively reviewed all patients diagnosed with PNES by vEEG following standard seizure induction practices over a 21-month period. Within this cohort, we established the prevalence of coexisting epilepsy using clinical and electrographic data acquired from our epilepsy-specific patient record. We identified patients with simultaneous PNES and ES recorded during a single vEEG admission, establishing the frequency and emergent timing of each type. Of our 262 monitored patients, 59 were diagnosed with PNES. Nineteen of the patients with PNES had coexisting epilepsy (prevalence rate of 7.3% or 32% of those with PNES). Sixteen patients had PNES and ES recorded during the same admission, and the remaining three patients had sequential PNES following successful treatment of ES. PNES occurred earlier (mean, within 1.21 days), with ES occurring later (mean, within 4.86 days). The simultaneous occurrence of PNES and ES recorded during a single admission is more common than previously reported. Identifying this group of patients may require a significantly longer period of vEEG monitoring and a detailed analysis of each individual's historical seizure events.
癫痫和精神性非癫痫发作(PNES)可能并存,且可能以两种形式出现:相继出现和同时出现。在相继出现的情况下,癫痫发作(ES)得到治疗,而PNES随后出现。视频脑电图(vEEG)对ES和PNES的同步记录描述较少。我们回顾性分析了在21个月期间按照标准癫痫发作诱发方法通过vEEG诊断为PNES的所有患者。在这个队列中,我们利用从我们特定于癫痫的患者记录中获取的临床和脑电图数据确定了并存癫痫的患病率。我们确定了在单次vEEG住院期间记录到同时存在PNES和ES的患者,确定了每种类型的发作频率和出现时间。在我们监测的262例患者中,59例被诊断为PNES。其中19例PNES患者并存癫痫(患病率为7.3%,或占PNES患者的32%)。16例患者在同一住院期间记录到PNES和ES,其余3例患者在ES成功治疗后出现相继的PNES。PNES出现较早(平均在1.21天内),而ES出现较晚(平均在4.86天内)。单次住院期间记录到的PNES和ES同时出现的情况比以前报道的更为常见。识别这组患者可能需要显著更长时间的vEEG监测以及对每个个体既往癫痫发作事件进行详细分析。