Department of Medicine and Interdepartmental Division of Critical Care Medicine, Sinai Health System, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Lawrence S. Bloomberg Faculty of Nursing and Interdepartmental Division of Critical Care Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Crit Care Med. 2018 Jun;46(6):991-996. doi: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000003114.
To review women's participation as faculty at five critical care conferences over 7 years.
Retrospective analysis of five scientific programs to identify the proportion of females and each speaker's profession based on conference conveners, program documents, or internet research.
Three international (European Society of Intensive Care Medicine, International Symposium on Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine, Society of Critical Care Medicine) and two national (Critical Care Canada Forum, U.K. Intensive Care Society State of the Art Meeting) annual critical care conferences held between 2010 and 2016.
Female faculty speakers.
None.
Male speakers outnumbered female speakers at all five conferences, in all 7 years. Overall, women represented 5-31% of speakers, and female physicians represented 5-26% of speakers. Nursing and allied health professional faculty represented 0-25% of speakers; in general, more than 50% of allied health professionals were women. Over the 7 years, Society of Critical Care Medicine had the highest representation of female (27% overall) and nursing/allied health professional (16-25%) speakers; notably, male physicians substantially outnumbered female physicians in all years (62-70% vs 10-19%, respectively). Women's representation on conference program committees ranged from 0% to 40%, with Society of Critical Care Medicine having the highest representation of women (26-40%). The female proportions of speakers, physician speakers, and program committee members increased significantly over time at the Society of Critical Care Medicine and U.K. Intensive Care Society State of the Art Meeting conferences (p < 0.05), but there was no temporal change at the other three conferences.
There is a speaker gender gap at critical care conferences, with male faculty outnumbering female faculty. This gap is more marked among physician speakers than those speakers representing nursing and allied health professionals. Several organizational strategies can address this gender gap.
回顾 7 年来 5 次重症监护会议上女性作为教员的参与情况。
对 5 个科学项目进行回顾性分析,根据会议召集人、项目文件或互联网研究确定女性的比例和每位发言者的职业。
2010 年至 2016 年期间举办的 3 次国际(欧洲重症监护医学学会、国际重症监护和急诊医学研讨会、重症监护医学学会)和 2 次国家(加拿大重症监护论坛、英国重症监护学会最新进展会议)年度重症监护会议。
女性教员发言者。
无。
在所有 5 次会议中,所有 7 年中男性发言者的数量均多于女性发言者。总体而言,女性发言者占 5-31%,女性医师占 5-26%。护理和相关专业人员的教员占 0-25%;一般来说,超过 50%的相关专业人员为女性。在过去 7 年中,重症监护医学学会的女性(总体占 27%)和护理/相关专业人员(16-25%)发言者比例最高;值得注意的是,在所有年份中,男性医师的人数都大大超过女性医师(分别为 62-70%和 10-19%)。会议项目委员会成员中女性的比例从 0%到 40%不等,重症监护医学学会的女性比例最高(26-40%)。随着时间的推移,重症监护医学学会和英国重症监护学会最新进展会议的女性发言者、医师发言者和项目委员会成员的比例显著增加(p<0.05),但其他 3 个会议没有时间变化。
重症监护会议存在发言者性别差距,男性教员多于女性教员。这种差距在医师发言者中比护理和相关专业人员更为明显。一些组织策略可以解决这一性别差距。