Schemmann Heike, Rensing Nadine, Zalpour Christoff
Osnabrueck University of Applied Sciences, Albrechtstrasse 30, 49076 Osnabrueck, Germany. Tel +49 (0)541 969-3114.
Med Probl Perform Art. 2018 Mar;33(1):56-71. doi: 10.21091/mppa.2018.1009.
The aim of the study was to identify and systematically categorize musculoskeletal assessments used in quantitatively based studies about posture and movement in musicians playing high string instruments (violin, viola) in order to inform further research and help to identify gaps in knowledge.
A systematic literature search was conducted in the databases Cochrane, CINAHL, and PubMed as well as the journal Medical Problems of Performing Artists. Additional studies were searched within the reference lists of relevant articles. Sixty-four studies conducted since 1999 until May 2017 were included according to predefined inclusion criteria.
Various biomechanical measurement instruments were used in 24 of the selected studies in order to collect two- and three-dimensional kinematic data: optoelectronic systems with active and passive markers, electromagnetic systems, ultrasonic motion analysis systems, and image-based analysis of posture. In 11 studies, kinetics were measured by optoelectronic systems, force sensors, and a posturographic device. Further studies used electromyography to evaluate muscle activity (19 studies) as well as instruments to measure range of motion (2 studies). Additionally, a broad range of clinical examination techniques (35 studies) and self-reports (36 studies) were used to assess the musculoskeletal system of high string players.
The identified assessments could be used both in further research and in practical work in order to evaluate posture and movement in high string players. For future research, qualitatively based studies as well as psychometrically tested quantitatively based self-report assessments are required.
本研究旨在识别并系统分类在关于演奏高音弦乐器(小提琴、中提琴)的音乐家姿势和动作的定量研究中所使用的肌肉骨骼评估方法,以便为进一步研究提供信息,并有助于找出知识空白。
在Cochrane、CINAHL和PubMed数据库以及《表演艺术家的医学问题》期刊中进行了系统的文献检索。在相关文章的参考文献列表中搜索了其他研究。根据预先定义的纳入标准,纳入了1999年至2017年5月期间进行的64项研究。
在24项选定研究中使用了各种生物力学测量仪器来收集二维和三维运动学数据:带有主动和被动标记的光电系统、电磁系统、超声运动分析系统以及基于图像的姿势分析。在11项研究中,通过光电系统、力传感器和姿势描记装置测量动力学。其他研究使用肌电图来评估肌肉活动(19项研究)以及测量运动范围的仪器(2项研究)。此外,还使用了广泛的临床检查技术(35项研究)和自我报告(36项研究)来评估高音弦乐器演奏者的肌肉骨骼系统。
所识别的评估方法可用于进一步研究和实际工作中,以评估高音弦乐器演奏者的姿势和动作。对于未来的研究,需要基于定性的研究以及经过心理测量测试的基于定量的自我报告评估。