Nehete Sushil Ramesh, Raut Binita B, Hiremath Amita S, Thatte R Mukund
Department of Plastic Surgery, Bombay Hospital and Institute of Medical Sciences, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Indian J Plast Surg. 2017 Sep-Dec;50(3):260-265. doi: 10.4103/ijps.IJPS_41_17.
We aimed to study the various clinical and electrophysiological parameters of severity of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) and to see if the severity of CTS affects recovery after surgery.
A prospective study of 35 patients suffering from CTS. Clinical severity was assessed using visual analogue scale and standard questionnaires such as Levine and Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaires. All the patients underwent electrophysiological evaluation to assess electrophysiological severity of CTS. According to modified Padua classification, they were classified into three groups, namely, minimal to mild, moderate and severe to extreme. All patients underwent Carpal tunnel release in our unit. The clinical assessment was repeated 3 months post-operatively.
Out of 33 patients, majority (65.7%) of the patients were suffering from moderately severe CTS. The clinical provocative tests were positive in majority of patients. Clinically and statistically significant ( < 0.001) improvement was seen in all clinical severity scores. However, it did not show any statistical correlation with electrophysiological severity of the disease when compared among the groups. There was no association of age, gender of the patient, body mass index, hand dominance, affected side of the patient, results of provocative tests and the presence or absence of thenar muscle atrophy when compared among the three severity groups ( > 0.05).
Although pre-operative clinical scores of severity and electrophysiology have a diagnostic role in CTS, they do not correlate with post-operative recovery and in turn fail to predict the extent of post-operative recovery before surgery.
我们旨在研究腕管综合征(CTS)严重程度的各种临床和电生理参数,并观察CTS的严重程度是否会影响手术后的恢复情况。
对35例CTS患者进行前瞻性研究。使用视觉模拟量表和标准问卷(如莱文问卷以及手臂、肩部和手部功能障碍问卷)评估临床严重程度。所有患者均接受电生理评估以评估CTS的电生理严重程度。根据改良的帕多瓦分类法,将他们分为三组,即轻度至中度、中度和重度至极重度。所有患者均在我们科室接受了腕管松解术。术后3个月重复进行临床评估。
在33例患者中,大多数(65.7%)患者患有中度至重度CTS。大多数患者的临床激发试验呈阳性。所有临床严重程度评分均有临床和统计学意义(<0.001)的改善。然而,在各组之间比较时,其与疾病的电生理严重程度没有显示出任何统计学相关性。在三个严重程度组之间比较时,患者的年龄、性别、体重指数、用手习惯、患侧、激发试验结果以及大鱼际肌萎缩的有无均无关联(>0.05)。
虽然术前临床严重程度评分和电生理检查在CTS中有诊断作用,但它们与术后恢复情况无关,进而无法在手术前预测术后恢复程度。