Jepsen Jørgen Riis
Dan Med J. 2018 Apr;65(4).
Diagnostic consensus criteria cannot be applied in a major proportion of patients with upper limb complaints, many of which are regarded as "non-specific". The three empirical studies in this thesis aimed to address this diagnostic challenge by incorporating representative neurological qualities in the physical examination. Patterns of muscle weakness, sensory abnormalities and nerve trunk allodynia based on the nerves' topography and their motor and cutaneous innervation were defined to reflect peripheral nerve afflictions and their locations. The physical examination was first validated on patients in clinical occupational medicine. Next, the neurological patterns were studied among computer operators in order to contribute to the characterization of their disorder. Finally, self-reported work-exposures for patients in general practice presenting with symptoms and findings consistent with brachial plexopathy were compared with the exposures of matched control patients without upper limb symptoms. The inter-rater reliability of manual individual muscle testing, and of assessments of sensibility (touch, pinprick and vibration) and mechanosensitivity of nerve trunks was generally moderate to good. Patterns of findings in accordance with neuropathy at ten locations were identified with moderate to good reliability. The identified patterns reflected the presence of symptoms with high positive and negative predictive values. An examination limited to the assessment of strength in six muscles was shown to be sensitive but non-specific. Computer operators with severe upper limb complaints are characterized by rather uniform physical findings in accordance with an infraclavicular brachial plexopathy in combination with median and posterior interosseous neuropathy at elbow level. In spite of reduced symptoms at follow-up, the prognosis in terms of work-status and persisting pain is serious. A cross-sectional study of computer operators in current work showed that individual and patterns of neurological findings in symptomatic subjects reflected these three locations of focal neuropathy. Pain was common in the studied sample, but of low intensity. Physical abnormalities were frequent and related to summarized pain. Patterns in accordance with brachial plexopathy, and median (elbow) and posterior interosseous neuropathies were identified in a minor proportion of limbs, in particular in the mouse-operating limb. A stretching course designed to improve the mobility and available space for the nerves at the three locations reduced the pain level but did not influence physical findings at follow-up. The relation of symptoms to the identified neurological patterns and the effect of stretching provide additional support to the construct validity of the applied neurological examination. This study indicates the role of nerve afflictions in computer-related upper limb disorders. The most frequent pattern in the first two studies was in accordance with brachial plexopathy. Therefore additional analyses addressed the relation of this condition to me-chanical exposures at work. Whether assessed as the extent during the workday or days per week, many exposures, in particular adverse upper limb postures, repetitive work, work pace, and the use of force, were significant risk indicators for brachial plexopathy with clear dose-response relationships. The identification of patterns of physical findings that reflect the function of the peripheral nerves appears to be a rewarding diagnostic procedure in subjects with upper limb symptoms. The relation of patterns to symptoms indicates the diagnostic feasibility of the examination and can contribute to explain symptoms in workers such as computer operators. Patterns in accordance with brachial plexopathy are frequent and related to mechanical work-exposures.
诊断共识标准无法应用于大部分有上肢不适症状的患者,其中许多被视为“非特异性”。本论文中的三项实证研究旨在通过在体格检查中纳入具有代表性的神经学特征来应对这一诊断挑战。基于神经的解剖位置及其运动和皮肤支配,定义了肌肉无力、感觉异常和神经干异常性疼痛的模式,以反映周围神经病变及其位置。首先在临床职业医学患者中对体格检查进行验证。接下来,对计算机操作员进行神经学模式研究,以有助于对他们的病症进行特征描述。最后,将全科医疗中出现与臂丛神经病变一致的症状和体征的患者自我报告的工作暴露情况与无上肢症状的匹配对照患者的暴露情况进行比较。手动进行的个体肌肉测试、感觉(触觉、针刺觉和振动觉)评估以及神经干机械敏感性评估的评分者间信度总体为中等至良好。在十个部位识别出的符合神经病变的体征模式具有中等至良好的信度。所识别的模式反映出症状的存在,具有较高的阳性和阴性预测价值。一项仅限于评估六块肌肉力量的检查显示具有敏感性,但不具有特异性。有严重上肢不适症状的计算机操作员具有相当一致的体格检查结果,符合锁骨下臂丛神经病变,并伴有肘部水平的正中神经和骨间后神经病变。尽管随访时症状有所减轻,但就工作状态和持续疼痛而言,预后严重。一项对在职计算机操作员的横断面研究表明,有症状受试者的个体和神经学体征模式反映了这三个局灶性神经病变的部位。在所研究的样本中疼痛很常见,但强度较低。身体异常频繁出现且与汇总的疼痛有关。符合臂丛神经病变以及正中神经(肘部)和骨间后神经病变的模式在少数肢体中被识别出来,特别是在操作鼠标的肢体中。一个旨在改善三个部位神经的活动度和可用空间而设计的伸展疗程降低了疼痛程度,但在随访时并未影响体格检查结果。症状与所识别的神经学模式之间的关系以及伸展的效果为所应用的神经学检查的结构效度提供了额外支持。这项研究表明神经病变在与计算机相关的上肢疾病中的作用。前两项研究中最常见的模式符合臂丛神经病变。因此,进一步的分析探讨了这种情况与工作中的机械暴露之间的关系。无论是按工作日的时长还是每周的天数来评估,许多暴露,特别是不良的上肢姿势、重复性工作、工作节奏以及用力情况,都是臂丛神经病变的显著风险指标,且存在明确的剂量反应关系。识别反映周围神经功能的体格检查结果模式似乎是对有上肢症状的受试者进行诊断的一种有效方法。模式与症状之间的关系表明了该检查的诊断可行性,并有助于解释计算机操作员等工人的症状。符合臂丛神经病变的模式很常见,且与机械性工作暴露有关。