R.F. Baugh is professor, chief of otolaryngology, and assistant dean for admissions, University of Toledo College of Medicine and Life Sciences, Toledo, Ohio.
Acad Med. 2018 Sep;93(9):1281-1285. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000002235.
Ignoring the diverse and rich cultures and histories of Africa and the African diaspora by applying the term African American to anyone of sub-Saharan African ancestry in medical school admissions does a disservice to applicants, medical schools, and the communities they serve. To determine how applicants can contribute to a diverse educational environment, admissions decisions must go beyond racial and ethnic self-reporting and recognize the diversity that applicants bring to their medical school. Using a holistic approach, institutions can fairly evaluate applicants and strategically fill their incoming classes. What each medical school is looking for based on its mission and how each student reflects that mission and enhances the educational environment should be revisited as each application is considered. Medical schools must adopt practices that strategically enroll applicants who help achieve their mission and better the communities they serve. The benefits of diversity are not achieved in a linear fashion but require a critical mass for each diverse group. Different strategies are needed to enhance the educational environment, address underrepresentation in medicine, and eliminate health disparities. If racial justice and health equity are to be realized, diversity policies need to recognize the differences between African and Afro Caribbean immigrants and African Americans.In this Perspective, the author argues for distinguishing between these groups in medical school admissions. He explores the differences in their history, culture, and experiences and demonstrates their uniqueness. He concludes by discussing diversity in medicine and offering suggestions for considering diversity in medical school admissions.
在医学院招生中,将任何具有撒哈拉以南非洲血统的人都称为“非裔美国人”,而忽略非洲和非裔散居地的多样而丰富的文化和历史,这对申请人、医学院和他们所服务的社区都是不利的。为了确定申请人如何为多元化的教育环境做出贡献,招生决策必须超越种族和族裔自我报告,并认识到申请人为医学院带来的多样性。通过采用整体方法,机构可以公平地评估申请人,并战略性地填补他们的新生班级。在考虑每个申请时,应该重新审视每所医学院根据其使命寻找的内容以及每个学生如何反映该使命并增强教育环境。医学院必须采取策略性的招生实践,招收有助于实现其使命并改善其服务社区的申请人。多样性的好处不是以线性方式实现的,而是每个多元化群体都需要达到一定的临界质量。需要采取不同的策略来增强教育环境,解决医学领域代表性不足的问题,并消除健康差距。如果要实现种族正义和健康公平,多样性政策就需要认识到非洲和加勒比移民与非裔美国人之间的差异。在这篇观点文章中,作者主张在医学院招生中区分这些群体。他探讨了他们在历史、文化和经验方面的差异,并展示了他们的独特性。最后,他讨论了医学领域的多样性,并就考虑医学院招生中的多样性提出了建议。