Stanford Research into the Impact of Tobacco Advertising, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA.
Department of Otolaryngology, Stanford University, Stanford, California, USA.
Tob Control. 2019 Jan;28(1):67-73. doi: 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2017-054175. Epub 2018 Apr 5.
Facebook has a comprehensive set of policies intended to inhibit promotion and sales of tobacco products. Their effectiveness has yet to be studied.
Leading tobacco brands (388) were identified via Nielsen and Ranker databases and 108 were found to maintain brand-sponsored Facebook pages. Key indicators of alignment with Facebook policy were evaluated.
Purchase links (eg, 'shop now' button) on brand-sponsored pages were found for hookah tobaccos (41%), e-cigarettes (74%), smokeless (50%) and cigars (31%). Sales promotions (eg, discount coupons) were present in hookah tobacco (48%), e-cigarette (76%) and cigar (69%) brand-sponsored pages. While conventional cigarettes did not maintain brand-sponsored pages, they were featured in 80% of online tobacco vendors' Facebook pages. The requirement for age gating, to exclude those <18 from viewing tobacco promotion, was absent in hookah tobacco (78%), e-cigarette (62%) and cigar (21%) brand-sponsored pages and for 90% of online tobacco stores which promote leading cigarette brands (eg, Marlboro, Camel). Many of the brand-sponsored tobacco product pages had thousands of 'likes'.
It is laudable that Facebook has policies intended to interdict tobacco promotion throughout its platform. Nevertheless, widespread tobacco promotion and sales were found at variance with the company's policies governing advertising, commerce, page content and under age access. Vetting could be improved by automated screening in partnership with human reviewers.
Facebook 制定了一套全面的政策,旨在抑制烟草产品的推广和销售。但这些政策的效果尚未得到研究。
通过尼尔森和 Ranker 数据库确定了领先的烟草品牌(388 个),并发现其中 108 个品牌维持着品牌赞助的 Facebook 页面。评估了与 Facebook 政策一致性的关键指标。
在品牌赞助的页面上发现了水烟烟草(41%)、电子烟(74%)、无烟烟草(50%)和雪茄(31%)的购买链接(例如“立即购买”按钮)。销售促销(例如折扣券)存在于水烟烟草(48%)、电子烟(76%)和雪茄(69%)品牌赞助的页面中。虽然传统香烟没有维持品牌赞助的页面,但它们出现在 80%的在线烟草零售商的 Facebook 页面中。年龄限制的要求,即排除 18 岁以下人群查看烟草促销内容,在水烟烟草(78%)、电子烟(62%)和雪茄(21%)品牌赞助页面以及 90%的在线烟草商店中都没有得到遵守,这些商店推销领先的香烟品牌(例如万宝路、骆驼)。许多品牌赞助的烟草产品页面都有成千上万的“点赞”。
值得称赞的是,Facebook 制定了旨在禁止其平台上烟草推广的政策。然而,在其平台上广泛存在的烟草推广和销售与该公司管理广告、商业、页面内容和未成年访问的政策不一致。审查可以通过与人工审查员合作的自动筛选来改进。