Artama Miia, Rinta-Kokko Hanna, Nohynek Hanna, Jokinen Jukka, Palmu Arto A
National Institute for Health and Welfare, Department of Public Health Solutions, Public Health Evaluation and Assessment Unit, Tampere, Finland.
National Institute for Health and Welfare, Department of Public Health Solutions, Public Health Evaluation and Assessment Unit, Helsinki, Finland.
Curr Drug Saf. 2018;13(2):107-112. doi: 10.2174/1574886313666180406164151.
In clinical trials of Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccines (PCV), some adverse events have been reported more frequently in the PCV vaccinated. Ten-valent PCV (PCV10) was introduced into the Finnish National Vaccination Programme (NVP) in September 2010.
We conducted an ecologic register-based study to investigate further the reported adverse events after PCV.
This study included data obtained from the Finnish nationwide, population-based registers. First diagnoses of febrile seizures, breath-holding, urticarial rash, asthma and Kawasaki's disease were included as outcomes obtained from the hospital discharge register. Data from Finnish Population Register during 2000-2014 for children age from 3 months to 10 years were used to estimate annual incidence rates. Incidence rate ratios of the outcomes were calculated between the target cohort of children eligible for PCV10 during 2010-2014 and a reference cohort before the NVP introduction (2004-2008).
No increases in the incidence of the adverse events after PCV10 introduction were found except for urticarial rash (incidence rate 2.48 vs. 1.60/1000 pyrs; incidence rate ratio, 1.54;95% CI 1.42-1.67). This increase was seen also in the unvaccinated older age groups in the post-vaccination era. The higher incidence of urticarial rash after the PCV10 introduction was due to the inclusion of diagnoses made in general medicine specialty in the discharge register because of a concomitant administrative change.
The results do not support public health concerns related to the previously reported adverse events. Concomitant changes in health care administration and coding introduced bias, which was controlled after further evaluation of the data. We consider this register-based approach with realworld data feasible in the signal validation process after any signal detection.
在肺炎球菌结合疫苗(PCV)的临床试验中,接种PCV疫苗的人群中一些不良事件的报告更为频繁。2010年9月,十价PCV(PCV10)被纳入芬兰国家疫苗接种计划(NVP)。
我们开展了一项基于登记册的生态学研究,以进一步调查接种PCV疫苗后报告的不良事件。
本研究纳入了从芬兰全国性、基于人群的登记册中获取的数据。首次诊断为热性惊厥、屏气发作、荨麻疹、哮喘和川崎病作为从医院出院登记册中获得的结果。使用2000年至2014年期间芬兰人口登记册中3个月至10岁儿童的数据来估计年发病率。计算2010年至2014年期间符合PCV10接种条件的目标儿童队列与NVP引入之前(2004年至2008年)的参考队列之间的结果发病率比。
除荨麻疹外,引入PCV10后不良事件的发病率没有增加(发病率分别为2.48 vs. 1.60/1000人年;发病率比,1.54;95% CI 1.42 - 1.67)。在接种疫苗后的时代,未接种疫苗的老年人群中也出现了这种增加。引入PCV10后荨麻疹发病率较高是由于出院登记册中纳入了因行政变更而在普通内科专科做出的诊断。
结果不支持与先前报告的不良事件相关的公共卫生担忧。医疗保健管理和编码的同时变化引入了偏差,在对数据进行进一步评估后得到了控制。我们认为这种基于登记册的方法结合实际数据在任何信号检测后的信号验证过程中是可行的。