University of Southern Denmark.
J Pers. 2019 Apr;87(2):267-275. doi: 10.1111/jopy.12388. Epub 2018 May 13.
We study personality traits of Danish parliamentarians (MPs) and examine elite-voter congruence and elite differentiation. Whereas previous political elite studies have focused only on the Big Five level, we include aspect-level differences.
In a highly representative survey of Danish MPs (N = 81; response rate = 46.3%) and a representative study of Danish voters (N = 3,612), we used the 60-item NEO-PI-R short version to examine personality differences on the Big Five level and, based on the NEO-BFAS, the aspect level.
MPs were more extraverted, conscientious, and open than the average voter. On the elite level, liberal MPs were more agreeable and, on the aspect level, more compassionate but not more polite than conservative MPs. MPs in center parties had stronger power aspirations and were less agreeable and more extraverted than MPs in peripheral parties. On the aspect level, MPs in center parties were more assertive and enthusiastic and less polite. Conscientiousness and Agreeableness were associated with power aspiration, but Extraversion was not because the assertiveness effect was suppressed by a non-effect for enthusiasm.
The inclusion of the aspect level explains null findings at the Big Five level and adds important nuances to the personality portrait of political elites.
我们研究丹麦议员的人格特质,并探讨精英与选民的一致性和差异性。虽然之前的政治精英研究仅集中在大五人格层面,但我们包括了方面层面的差异。
在一项针对丹麦议员(N=81;回应率=46.3%)的高度代表性调查和一项针对丹麦选民(N=3612)的代表性研究中,我们使用 NEO-PI-R 60 项短版问卷来检验大五人格层面的人格差异,并基于 NEO-BFAS 检验方面层面的差异。
议员比普通选民更加外向、尽责和开放。在精英层面上,自由派议员更加友善,而在方面层面上,更加富有同情心但不更有礼貌,相比保守派议员。中间党派的议员更有权力欲望,不如外围党派的议员那么友善和外向。在方面层面上,中间党派的议员更加自信和热情,也不那么礼貌。尽责和宜人性与权力欲望有关,但外向性无关,因为热情的非效应抑制了自信的效应。
包括方面层面解释了大五人格层面的无效发现,并为政治精英的人格画像增添了重要的细微差别。