Bae Kwang-Ho, Jeong Young-Seok, Go Ho-Yeon, Sun Seung-Ho, Kim Tae-Hoon, Jung Ki-Yong, Song Yun-Kyung, Ko Seong-Gyu, Choi You-Kyung, Park Jong-Hyeong, Lee Siwoo, Lee Youngseop, Jeon Chan-Yong
Mibyeong Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Department of Korean Internal Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Se-Myung University, Jecheon, Korea.
Integr Med Res. 2018 Mar;7(1):61-67. doi: 10.1016/j.imr.2017.11.001. Epub 2017 Nov 16.
Cold hypersensitivity in the hands and feet (CHHF) is a symptom patients usually feel cold in their hands and feet, but not dealt with a disease in western medicine. However, it is often appealed by patients at a clinic of Korean medicine (KM), considered to be a sort of key diagnostic indicator, and actively treated by physicians. Nevertheless, there is no standardized diagnostic definition for CHHF. Therefore, we surveyed KM experts' opinions to address the clinical definition, diagnostic criteria, and other relevant things on CHHF.
We developed a survey to assess the definition, diagnosis, causes, and accompanying symptoms on CHHF. 31 experts who work at specialized university hospitals affiliated with KM hospitals consented to participation. Experts responded to survey questions by selecting multiple-choice answers or stating their opinions.
Vast majority of experts (83.8%) agreed with our definition on CHHF ("a feeling of cold as a symptom; that one's hands or feet become colder than those of average people in temperatures that are not normally perceived as cold"). 77.4% of experts considered subjective symptoms on CHHF were more important than medical instrument results. Constitution or genetic factors (87.1%) and stress (64.5%) were the most common causes reported for CHHF.
This study offers an expert consensus regarding the themes, opinions, and experiences of practitioners with CHHF. Our results underscore the need for standardized definitions and diagnostic criteria for CHHF.
手足冷过敏(CHHF)是一种患者常感觉手足发冷的症状,但在西医中并非一种疾病。然而,在韩医诊所中,它常被患者提及,被视为一种关键的诊断指标,并受到医生的积极治疗。然而,对于CHHF尚无标准化的诊断定义。因此,我们调查了韩医专家对于CHHF的临床定义、诊断标准及其他相关事项的意见。
我们设计了一项调查,以评估CHHF的定义、诊断、病因及伴随症状。31位在韩医医院附属的专业大学医院工作的专家同意参与。专家们通过选择多项选择题答案或陈述意见来回答调查问卷。
绝大多数专家(83.8%)同意我们对CHHF的定义(“一种以寒冷感为症状;在通常不被视为寒冷的温度下,手足比普通人更冷”)。77.4%的专家认为CHHF的主观症状比医学仪器检测结果更重要。体质或遗传因素(87.1%)和压力(64.5%)是报告的CHHF最常见病因。
本研究提供了关于CHHF从业者的主题、意见和经验的专家共识。我们的结果强调了对CHHF进行标准化定义和诊断标准的必要性。