Ng Qin Xiang, De Deyn Michelle Lee Zhi Qing, Venkatanarayanan Nandini, Ho Collin Yih Xian, Yeo Wee-Song
Department of Medicine, National University Hospital, National University Health System, Singapore.
MOH Holdings Pte Ltd, Singapore.
J Inflamm Res. 2018 Mar 28;11:135-142. doi: 10.2147/JIR.S160964. eCollection 2018.
Stevens-Johnson syndrome (SJS) and toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN) are dermatologic emergencies with high morbidity and mortality risk. Cyclosporine, an immunomodulatory agent, is sometimes used off-label, and its role continues to be debated. This meta-analysis aimed to provide an update of current evidence and to clarify the role of cyclosporine in SJS/TEN treatment better.
Using the keywords [cyclosporine OR cyclosporine OR ciclosporin OR CsA] AND [Steven-Johnson OR SJS OR toxic epidermal OR epidermal necrolysis OR TEN OR hypersensitivity OR dermatologic OR burns], a preliminary search on the PubMed, Ovid, Web of Science, and Google Scholar Database yielded 615 papers published in English between January1, 1960 and July 1, 2017. The inclusion criteria for this review were: 1) published retrospective or prospective study (excluding single case reports); 2) patients with clinical diagnosis of SJS or TEN; 3) trial of cyclosporine treatment; and 4) available survival/mortality data.
A total of 12 studies, with a total of 358 SJS/TEN patients were reviewed. Two studies were excluded from the meta-analysis as they did not report SCORe of toxic epidermal necrosis/predicted mortality data; one was excluded because of possible data irregularities. Meta-analysis of nine studies revealed a significant reduction in mortality risk with cyclosporine therapy (standardized mortality ratio 0.320; 95% CI: 0.119-0.522; =0.002). Cyclosporine was also generally well tolerated with little adverse effects or increased infection, albeit the patients tended to be critically ill. Publication bias was observed in the funnel plot and Egger test (=0.0467).
Currently available evidence are predominantly open trials and retrospective studies with a significant risk of bias, perhaps owing to the rarity and life-threatening nature of the condition. Given its immunomodulatory actions, cyclosporine could be a potential treatment option for SJS/TEN in addition to best supportive measures. Further confirmation with robust randomized, controlled trials or larger case series is necessary and should be encouraged.
史蒂文斯 - 约翰逊综合征(SJS)和中毒性表皮坏死松解症(TEN)是具有高发病率和死亡风险的皮肤科急症。环孢素作为一种免疫调节剂,有时会被超适应症使用,其作用仍存在争议。本荟萃分析旨在更新当前证据,并更好地阐明环孢素在SJS/TEN治疗中的作用。
使用关键词[环孢素或环孢菌素或环孢霉素或CsA]和[史蒂文斯 - 约翰逊或SJS或中毒性表皮或表皮坏死松解症或TEN或超敏反应或皮肤科或烧伤],在PubMed、Ovid、科学网和谷歌学术数据库上进行初步检索,共得到1960年1月1日至2017年7月1日期间发表的615篇英文论文。本综述的纳入标准为:1)发表的回顾性或前瞻性研究(不包括单病例报告);2)临床诊断为SJS或TEN的患者;3)环孢素治疗试验;4)可获得生存/死亡率数据。
共纳入12项研究,总计358例SJS/TEN患者。两项研究因未报告中毒性表皮坏死评分/预测死亡率数据而被排除在荟萃分析之外;一项因可能的数据异常被排除。对9项研究的荟萃分析显示,环孢素治疗可显著降低死亡风险(标准化死亡率0.320;95%CI:0.119 - 0.522;P = 0.002)。环孢素总体耐受性良好,不良反应或感染增加较少,尽管患者往往病情危重。漏斗图和Egger检验显示存在发表偏倚(P = 0.0467)。
目前可得的证据主要是开放性试验和回顾性研究,存在显著的偏倚风险,这可能是由于该疾病的罕见性和危及生命的性质所致。鉴于其免疫调节作用,除了最佳支持措施外,环孢素可能是SJS/TEN的一种潜在治疗选择。有必要并应鼓励通过强有力的随机对照试验或更大规模的病例系列进行进一步证实。