Walt Lisa Christine, Jason Leonard A
Center for Community Research, DePaul University, Chicago IL.
ARC J Addict. 2017;2(1):1-8.
Women's incarceration rates have increased dramatically over recent years; with Black women's rates disproportionately and significantly higher than other races. Researchers have attempted to understand this criminal justice involvement disparity, and have suggested two major theoretical pathways Differential Involvement and Differential Selection Theories to explain these racial differences. We use the Differential Involvement Theory as a framework to discuss how the objective experience of economic disadvantage as measured by indicators of structural hardship including educational and employment under-attainment and the experience of psychological stress related to resource loss (because of this disadvantage) may explain women's engagement in criminal activity. In order to conceptualize psychological stress, we used Hobfoll's Conservation of Resource's (COR) Theory and measure. Next, we investigated the link between these factors and the degree (number of times incarcerated, number of months incarcerated in lifetime) of criminal behavior using baseline data collected from a NIH study that drew from a racially diverse sample of former substance abusing, criminally involved urban women. Results indicated potential racial differences in the perception of resource loss, and underscore the complex interaction of the experience of race, poverty, and the unique experience of stress on women's decision making and criminal justice involvement.
近年来,女性监禁率急剧上升;黑人女性的监禁率比其他种族高得多,且极不成比例。研究人员试图理解这种刑事司法参与方面的差异,并提出了两种主要的理论途径——差异参与理论和差异选择理论——来解释这些种族差异。我们以差异参与理论为框架,讨论以结构性困境指标衡量的经济劣势的客观经历,包括教育程度和就业不足,以及(由于这种劣势)与资源损失相关的心理压力经历,如何解释女性参与犯罪活动的情况。为了概念化心理压力,我们使用了霍布福尔的资源守恒(COR)理论及测量方法。接下来,我们利用从一项美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)研究收集的基线数据,调查了这些因素与犯罪行为程度(终身监禁次数、终身监禁月数)之间的联系,该研究抽取了有吸毒史、涉及犯罪的不同种族城市女性作为样本。结果表明,在资源损失认知方面可能存在种族差异,并突显了种族、贫困经历以及压力的独特体验在女性决策和刑事司法参与方面的复杂相互作用。