Oliver Andre', Andemeskel Ghilamichael, King Carlise R, Wallace Lyndsey, McDougal Serie, Monteiro Kenneth P, Ben-Zeev Avi
Department of Psychology, San Francisco State University, 1600 Holloway Avenue, EP 301, San Francisco, CA 94132-4168, USA.
College of Ethnic Studies, San Francisco State University, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Race Soc Probl. 2017 Dec;9(4):313-320. doi: 10.1007/s12552-017-9216-y. Epub 2017 Sep 27.
We provide evidence that stereotype threat, a phenomenon that causes stigmatized individuals to experience group-based evaluative concerns (Steele in Am Psychol 52:613-629, 1997; Whistling Vivaldi and other clues to how stereotypes affect us, W.W. Norton, New York, 2010), impacts affective aspects of Black identity as a function of majority versus minority ecological contexts. Black/African-American students, enrolled in either Africana Studies (Black ecological majority) or Psychology (Black ecological minority), completed private and public regard subscales from the Multidimensional Inventory of Black Identity (Sellers et al. in Pers Soc Psychol Rev 2:18-39, 1998) at baseline (Time 1) and after being randomly assigned to a stereotype threat or no-threat/control condition (Time 2). In threat, participants were introduced to a 'puzzle' task as diagnostic of intellectual abilities, whereas in no-threat the same task was introduced as culture fair, such that people from different racial/ethnic groups had performed similarly on this task in the past. In Psychology, students under threat exhibited a simultaneous decrease and increase in private and public regard, respectively, a pattern shown in the literature to be associated with discrimination-based distress and lesser well-being in Black ecological minority environments. In contrast, Africana Studies students' racial identity under threat remained intact. We discuss the protective effects of Africana Studies on racial identity and implications for educational reform.
我们提供的证据表明,刻板印象威胁这一现象(导致被污名化的个体体验到基于群体的评价性担忧,见斯蒂尔《美国心理学家》第52卷:613 - 629页,1997年;《吹奏维瓦尔第及其他关于刻板印象如何影响我们的线索》,W.W.诺顿出版社,纽约,2010年),作为多数与少数生态环境的函数,会影响黑人身份认同的情感方面。就读于非洲裔美国人研究专业(黑人生态多数群体)或心理学专业(黑人生态少数群体)的黑人/非裔美国学生,在基线期(时间1)以及被随机分配到刻板印象威胁组或无威胁/对照组后(时间2),完成了《黑人身份认同多维量表》(见塞勒斯等人《人格与社会心理学评论》第2卷:18 - 39页,1998年)中的私人与公众尊重分量表。在威胁组中,参与者被告知一项“拼图”任务是对智力能力的诊断,而在无威胁组中,同样的任务被介绍为文化公平的,即过去不同种族/族裔群体的人在这项任务上表现相似。在心理学专业中,受到威胁的学生在私人尊重方面同时下降,在公众尊重方面同时上升,文献表明这种模式与黑人生态少数群体环境中基于歧视的痛苦和较低的幸福感相关。相比之下,非洲裔美国人研究专业的学生在受到威胁时其种族身份保持不变。我们讨论了非洲裔美国人研究专业对种族身份的保护作用以及对教育改革的启示。