Smith Matthew
Soc Hist Med. 2017 Nov;30(4):767-787. doi: 10.1093/shm/hkw127. Epub 2017 Jan 18.
A recent study has claimed that the global rate of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is 5.29%. Any variation in such rates in specific studies, argue the authors, was due to methodological problems, rather than differences in the actual distribution of ADHD. Such reports strengthen the flawed notion that ADHD is a universal and essential disorder, found in all human populations across time and place. While it is true that the concept of ADHD has spread from the USA, where it emerged during the late 1950s, to most corners of the globe, such superficial pronouncements mask profound differences in how ADHD has been interpreted in different countries and regions. In this paper, I compare ADHD's emergence in Canada, the UK, Scandinavia, China and India, arguing that, while ADHD can be considered a global phenomenon, behavioural and educational imperfections remain very much a product of local historical, cultural and political factors.
最近一项研究称,全球注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)的发病率为5.29%。作者认为,特定研究中此类发病率的任何差异都是由于方法问题,而非ADHD实际分布的差异。此类报告强化了一种有缺陷的观念,即ADHD是一种普遍且本质性的疾病,在所有时间和地点的人群中都存在。虽然ADHD的概念确实已从20世纪50年代末在美国出现后传播到全球大部分地区,但这种表面的说法掩盖了不同国家和地区对ADHD的解读存在的深刻差异。在本文中,我比较了ADHD在加拿大、英国、斯堪的纳维亚、中国和印度的出现情况,认为虽然ADHD可被视为一种全球现象,但行为和教育方面的缺陷在很大程度上仍是当地历史、文化和政治因素的产物。