March Sonja, Day Jamin, Zieschank Kirsty, Ireland Michael
Institute for Resilient Regions, University of Southern Queensland, Springfield Central, Australia.
School of Psychology and Counselling, University of Southern Queensland, Ipswich, Australia.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 Apr 19;6(4):e90. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9456.
Early identification of child emotional and behavioral concerns is essential for the prevention of mental health problems; however, few suitable child-reported screening measures are available. Digital tools offer an exciting opportunity for obtaining clinical information from the child's perspective.
The aim of this study was to describe the initial development and pilot testing of the Interactive Child Distress Screener (ICDS). The ICDS is a Web-based screening instrument for the early identification of emotional and behavioral problems in children aged between 5 and 12 years.
This paper utilized a mixed-methods approach to (1) develop and refine item content using an expert review process (study 1) and (2) develop and refine prototype animations and an app interface using codesign with child users (study 2). Study 1 involved an iterative process that comprised the following four steps: (1) the initial development of target constructs, (2) preliminary content validation (face validity, item importance, and suitability for animation) from an expert panel of researchers and psychologists (N=9), (3) item refinement, and (4) a follow-up validation with the same expert panel. Study 2 also comprised four steps, which are as follows: (1) the development of prototype animations, (2) the development of the app interface and a response format, (3) child interviews to determine feasibility and obtain feedback, and (4) refinement of animations and interface. Cognitive interviews were conducted with 18 children aged between 4 and 12 years who tested 3 prototype animated items. Children were asked to describe the target behavior, how well the animations captured the intended behavior, and provide suggestions for improvement. Their ability to understand the wording of instructions was also assessed, as well as the general acceptability of character and sound design.
In study 1, a revised list of 15 constructs was generated from the first and second round of expert feedback. These were rated highly in terms of importance (mean 6.32, SD 0.42) and perceived compatibility of items (mean 6.41, SD 0.45) on a 7-point scale. In study 2, overall feedback regarding the character design and sounds was positive. Children's ability to understand intended behaviors varied according to target items, and feedback highlighted key objectives for improvements such as adding contextual cues or improving character detail. These design changes were incorporated through an iterative process, with examples presented.
The ICDS has potential to obtain clinical information from the child's perspective that may otherwise be overlooked. If effective, the ICDS will provide a quick, engaging, and easy-to-use screener that can be utilized in routine care settings. This project highlights the importance of involving an expert review and user codesign in the development of digital assessment tools for children.
早期识别儿童的情绪和行为问题对于预防心理健康问题至关重要;然而,适合儿童自我报告的筛查措施却很少。数字工具为从儿童视角获取临床信息提供了一个令人兴奋的机会。
本研究旨在描述交互式儿童苦恼筛查工具(ICDS)的初步开发和试点测试情况。ICDS是一种基于网络的筛查工具,用于早期识别5至12岁儿童的情绪和行为问题。
本文采用混合方法,(1)通过专家评审过程开发和完善项目内容(研究1),(2)与儿童用户进行协同设计,开发和完善原型动画及应用程序界面(研究2)。研究1包括一个迭代过程,该过程包含以下四个步骤:(1)目标结构的初步开发;(2)由一组研究人员和心理学家组成的专家小组(N = 9)进行初步内容验证(表面效度、项目重要性以及对动画的适用性);(3)项目细化;(4)与同一专家小组进行后续验证。研究2也包括四个步骤,如下:(1)原型动画的开发;(2)应用程序界面和响应格式的开发;(3)儿童访谈以确定可行性并获取反馈;(4)动画和界面的细化。对18名4至12岁的儿童进行了认知访谈,他们测试了3个原型动画项目。要求儿童描述目标行为、动画对预期行为的捕捉程度,并提供改进建议。还评估了他们理解说明文字的能力,以及角色和声音设计的总体可接受性。
在研究1中,根据第一轮和第二轮专家反馈生成了一份包含15个结构的修订清单。这些结构在7分制的重要性(平均6.32,标准差0.42)和项目感知兼容性(平均6.41,标准差0.45)方面得分很高。在研究2中,关于角色设计和声音的总体反馈是积极的。儿童理解预期行为的能力因目标项目而异,反馈突出了改进的关键目标,如添加背景线索或改善角色细节。这些设计更改通过迭代过程得以纳入,并给出了示例。
ICDS有潜力从儿童视角获取可能被忽视的临床信息。如果有效,ICDS将提供一种快速、有趣且易于使用的筛查工具,可在常规护理环境中使用。该项目凸显了在儿童数字评估工具开发中纳入专家评审和用户协同设计的重要性。