Rumende Cleopas Martin
Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia - Cipto Mangunkusumo Hospital, Jakarta, Indonesia.
Acta Med Indones. 2018 Jan;50(1):1-2.
In 2015, 10.4 million people developed tuberculosis (TB) and 580,000 amongst them suffered from multidrug-resistant TB (MDR-TB). From those 580,000 cases of MDR-TB, only 125,000 were detected and reported. A total of 111,000 people began to receive MDR-TB treatment in 2014 while 190,000 MDR-TB patients were estimated to have died, largely due to lack of access to effective treatment. The mechanism of drug resistance can be caused by genetic factors, factors related to previous treatment and other factors such as comorbidity with diabetes mellitus. Although there is some evidence which postulate host genetic predisposition is the basis for the development of MDR-TB, changes in the genomic content is the major underlying event in the emergence of variants strains in the M. tuberculosis complex. Spontaneous chromosomally-borne mutation occurring in M. tuberculosis at predictable rates are thought to confer resistance to anti-TB drugs. Factors related to previous anti-tuberculosis treatments consists of incomplete or inadequate treatment and also poor treatment adherence. A review of the published literature strongly suggest that the most powerful predictor for the presence of MDR-TB is a history of TB treatment. Many new cases of MDR-TB are created by physician's errors related to drugs regimen, dosing interval and duration of treatment. Multidrug-resistance TB developed due to error in TB management in the past such as initiation of an inadequat regimen using first line anti-TB drugs, the addition of single drug to a failing regimen, the failure to identify pre-existing resistance and variations in bioavailability of anti-TB drugs that predispose the patient to the development of MDR-TB. Non-adherence to prescribed treatment is often underestimated by physicians and difficult to predict. Certain factors such as psychiatric illness, alcoholism, drug additiction and homelessness can predict non-adherence to treatment. Poor compliance with the treatment is also an important factor in the development of acquired drug resistance.Diabetes mellitus has been a well-known risk factor for TB in the past. The global convergence of the accelerating type 2 DM pandemic, high TB prevalence and drug-resistant TB during the past couple of decades has become a serious challenge to clinicians worldwide. Over the past few years, some studies have shown that the treatment failure rate is higher in TB patients with DM as comorbidity. Moreover, there is significant association between DM an MDR-TB. There is higher chance of TB bacilli persistence to be present in sputum of pulmonary TB patient with DM than TB-only patient after 5 months treatment, and this persistence made it necessary for more longer treatment. Presence of DM in TB patients cause a longer period for sputum conversion, therefore it may become a major cause of poor treatment outcome in TB patients. Previous studies showed that a major mechanism for the emergence of drugs resistance in TB bacilli is random mutation in the bacterial genome and the pressure of selection by anti-TB drugs. Pulmonary TB in diabetic patients usually show higher mycobacterial loads at the initiation of treatment, hence they may have higher chance of bacillary mutation and the emergence of MDR-TB with the presenting of higher bacterial loads, longer treatment is needed to clear the bacteria. Therefore, it is not suprising that a higher chance of MDR-TB patients could be find in those patients. A pharmacokinetic study noted that plasma levels of rifampicin were 53% lower in TB patients with diabetes, which might affect treatment outcomes. Inadequate immune respons of the host may also be important in this negative effect of diabetes. Depressed production of IFN-γ in diabetic patients is related to decreasing immune response to TB infection. Reduction of IL-12 response to mycobacterial stimulation in leukocytes from TB with diabetic patients suggest a compromise of innate immune response.
2015年,1040万人罹患结核病,其中58万人患有耐多药结核病(MDR-TB)。在这58万例耐多药结核病病例中,仅12.5万例被检测和报告。2014年共有11.1万人开始接受耐多药结核病治疗,而估计有19万耐多药结核病患者死亡,主要原因是无法获得有效治疗。耐药机制可能由遗传因素、既往治疗相关因素以及其他因素(如合并糖尿病)引起。尽管有一些证据表明宿主遗传易感性是耐多药结核病发生的基础,但基因组内容的变化是结核分枝杆菌复合群中变异菌株出现的主要潜在事件。结核分枝杆菌中以可预测速率发生的自发染色体突变被认为赋予了对抗结核药物的耐药性。既往抗结核治疗相关因素包括治疗不完整或不充分以及治疗依从性差。对已发表文献的综述强烈表明,耐多药结核病存在的最有力预测因素是结核病治疗史。许多耐多药结核病新病例是由医生在药物方案、给药间隔和治疗持续时间方面的错误造成的。耐多药结核病是由于过去结核病管理中的错误而产生的,例如使用一线抗结核药物开始不充分的治疗方案、在治疗失败的方案中添加单一药物、未能识别预先存在的耐药性以及抗结核药物生物利用度的变化使患者易患耐多药结核病。医生往往低估了不遵守规定治疗的情况,而且难以预测。某些因素,如精神疾病、酗酒、药物成瘾和无家可归,可预测不遵守治疗的情况。治疗依从性差也是获得性耐药发生的一个重要因素。糖尿病过去一直是结核病的一个众所周知的危险因素。在过去几十年中,2型糖尿病大流行加速、结核病高患病率和耐药结核病在全球范围内的汇聚已成为全球临床医生面临的严峻挑战。在过去几年中,一些研究表明,合并糖尿病的结核病患者治疗失败率更高。此外,糖尿病与耐多药结核病之间存在显著关联。糖尿病合并肺结核患者在治疗5个月后,痰中结核杆菌持续存在的可能性高于单纯肺结核患者,这种持续存在使得需要更长时间的治疗。结核病患者中糖尿病的存在导致痰转阴时间延长,因此可能成为结核病患者治疗效果不佳的主要原因。既往研究表明,结核杆菌耐药性出现的主要机制是细菌基因组中的随机突变以及抗结核药物的选择压力。糖尿病患者的肺结核在治疗开始时通常显示出较高的分枝杆菌载量,因此他们可能有更高的细菌突变机会和耐多药结核病出现的机会,由于细菌载量较高,需要更长时间的治疗来清除细菌。因此,在这些患者中发现耐多药结核病患者的可能性更高也就不足为奇了。一项药代动力学研究指出,糖尿病结核病患者的利福平血浆水平低53%,这可能影响治疗结果。宿主免疫反应不足在糖尿病的这种负面影响中也可能很重要。糖尿病患者中γ-干扰素产生减少与对结核感染的免疫反应降低有关。糖尿病合并结核病患者白细胞中对分枝杆菌刺激的白细胞介素-12反应降低表明先天免疫反应受损。