Department of Audiology and Phoniatrics, Charité-University Medicine Berlin, Campus Charité Mitte, Charitéplatz 1, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Max-Planck Institute for Plasma Physics, Wendelsteinstraße 1, 17491 Greifswald, Germany.
Biomed Res Int. 2018 Mar 4;2018:3836714. doi: 10.1155/2018/3836714. eCollection 2018.
Voice range profile (VRP) and evaluation using the dysphonia severity index (DSI) represent essentials of instrument-based objective voice diagnostics and are implemented in different standardized registration programs. The respective measurement results, however, show differences. The aim of the study was to prove these differences statistically and to develop a new parameter, the Vocal Extent Measure (VEM), which is not influenced by the measurement program. VRPs of 97 subjects were recorded by two examiners using the established registration programs DiVAS (XION medical) and LingWAVES (WEVOSYS) simultaneously. The VEM was developed on the basis of VRP area and perimeter. All 194 VRP files were analyzed for various parameters and gender independence. The registration programs exhibited significant differences in several vocal parameters. A significant gender influence for DSI was found with DiVAS ( < 0.01), but not with LingWAVES. The VEM quantified the dynamic performance and frequency range by a unidimensional, interval-scaled value without unit, mostly between 0 and 120. This novel parameter represents an intelligible and user-friendly positive measure of vocal function, allows simple and stable VRP description, and seems to be suitable for quantification of vocal capacity. In contrast to DSI, the VEM proved to be less susceptible to registration program and gender.
嗓音障碍严重度量表(DSI)和嗓音障碍指数量表(VRP)是基于仪器的客观嗓音诊断的重要指标,分别在不同的标准化注册程序中实施。然而,各自的测量结果存在差异。本研究旨在通过统计学方法证明这些差异,并开发一个不受测量程序影响的新参数,即嗓音幅度测量(VEM)。由两名检查者使用已建立的 DiVAS(XION medical)和 LingWAVES(WEVOSYS)注册程序同时对 97 名受试者的嗓音进行了 VRP 记录。VEM 是基于 VRP 的面积和周长而开发的。对所有 194 个 VRP 文件进行了各种参数和性别独立性分析。两个注册程序在多个嗓音参数上存在显著差异。使用 DiVAS 发现 DSI 存在显著的性别影响(<0.01),而 LingWAVES 则没有。VEM 通过无单位的一维、区间标度值来量化动态性能和频率范围,其值通常在 0 到 120 之间。这个新参数代表了一种可理解且易于使用的嗓音功能正性度量,允许简单且稳定的 VRP 描述,并且似乎适合量化嗓音能力。与 DSI 相比,VEM 被证明对注册程序和性别不那么敏感。