Azogil-López Luis Miguel, Pérez-Lázaro Juan José, Ávila-Pecci Patricia, Medrano-Sánchez Esther María, Coronado-Vázquez María Valle
Consultorios de Los Marines y Cortelazor, Huelva, España.
Escuela Andaluza de Salud Pública, Granada, España.
Aten Primaria. 2019 May;51(5):278-284. doi: 10.1016/j.aprim.2018.02.006. Epub 2018 Apr 24.
The purpose of this study is to find out whether telephone referral from Primary Health Care to Internal Medicine Consult manages to reduce waiting days as compared to traditional referral. This study also aims to know how acceptable is the telephone referral to general practitioners and their patients.
No blind randomized controlled clinical trial.
Northern Huelva Health District.
154 patients.
Patients referrals from intervention clinicians were sent via telephone consultation, whereas patients referrals from control clinicians were sent by traditional via.
Number of days from referral request to Internal Medicine Consult. Number of telephone and traditional referrals. Number of doctors and patients denied. Denial reasons.
A statistically significant difference was found between groups, with an average of 27 (21-34) days. Among General Practitioners, 8 of the first 58 total doctors after randomization and, subsequently, 6 of the 20 doctors of the test group refused to engage in the trial because they considered "excessive time and effort consuming". 50% of patients referred by the 14 General Practitioners finally randomized to the intervention group were denied referral by telephone due to patient's complexity.
Telephone referral significantly reduces waiting days for Internal Medicine consult. This type of referral did not mean an "excessive time and effort consuming" to General Practitioners and was not all that beneficial to complex patients.
本研究旨在探究与传统转诊相比,从初级卫生保健机构通过电话转诊至内科会诊是否能减少等待天数。本研究还旨在了解电话转诊对于全科医生及其患者的可接受程度。
非盲随机对照临床试验。
韦尔瓦省北部卫生区。
154名患者。
干预组临床医生的患者转诊通过电话会诊进行,而对照组临床医生的患者转诊则通过传统方式进行。
从转诊请求到内科会诊的天数。电话转诊和传统转诊的数量。被拒绝的医生和患者数量。拒绝原因。
两组之间存在统计学上的显著差异,平均为27(21 - 34)天。在全科医生中,随机分组后的前58名医生中有8名,随后试验组的20名医生中有6名拒绝参与试验,因为他们认为“耗时费力”。最终随机分配到干预组的14名全科医生转诊的患者中,有50%因患者病情复杂而被电话转诊拒绝。
电话转诊显著减少了内科会诊的等待天数。这种转诊方式对全科医生来说并非“耗时费力”,但对病情复杂的患者并非十分有益。