Skeith Leslie, Ridinger Heather, Srinivasan Sushant, Givi Babak, Youssef Nazih, Harris Ilene
Division of Hematology and Hematological Malignancies, Department of Medicine, University of Calgary, Canada.
Department of Medicine, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, USA.
Int J Med Educ. 2018 Apr 27;9:113-121. doi: 10.5116/ijme.5abe.2209.
To explore the thesis experience of recent Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) graduates in the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC) program.
This is a qualitative case study exploring the experience of MHPE graduates between 2014 and 2016 (n=31). Using convenience sampling, all graduates with an email address (n=30) were invited to participate in an online survey and semi-structured interviews. Interviews were completed in-person or via telephone or video conference; interviewers collected detailed notes and audio recordings. Two authors independently analyzed the data iteratively using thematic analysis and discrepancies were discussed and resolved.
Survey results (n=20, 67%) revealed an average graduation of 5.1 years; 10 graduates (33%) were interviewed. Three themes related to the thesis experience were identified: success factors, challenges, and outcomes. Success factors, when present, promoted completion of a thesis; these included: a supportive program environment, time management, available resources, MHPE foundational coursework, aligning theses with career goals, and identifying a project with limited scope. Challenges made thesis completion more difficult for graduates; these included: institutional factors, personal or professional responsibilities, burnout, externally-imposed deadlines, and barriers in the research process. Despite these challenges, completing the thesis resulted in many professional or personal benefits (outcomes).
Multiple success factors and challenges were identified in the master's thesis process among MHPE graduates at UIC. These findings can help students conducting education-based scholarship through the master's thesis process. This study also informs program evaluation and improvements and outlines personal and professional outcomes of completing a master's thesis.
探讨伊利诺伊大学芝加哥分校(UIC)健康职业教育硕士(MHPE)项目近期毕业生的论文经历。
这是一项定性案例研究,探究2014年至2016年间MHPE毕业生(n = 31)的经历。采用便利抽样法,邀请所有有电子邮件地址的毕业生(n = 30)参与在线调查和半结构化访谈。访谈通过面对面、电话或视频会议完成;访谈者收集详细笔记和录音。两位作者使用主题分析法对数据进行反复独立分析,并讨论和解决差异。
调查结果(n = 20,67%)显示平均毕业时间为5.1年;10名毕业生(33%)接受了访谈。确定了与论文经历相关的三个主题:成功因素、挑战和成果。成功因素若存在,则会促进论文完成;这些因素包括:支持性的项目环境、时间管理、可用资源、MHPE基础课程作业、使论文与职业目标一致,以及确定范围有限的项目。挑战使毕业生完成论文更加困难;这些挑战包括:制度因素、个人或工作职责、倦怠、外部强加的期限,以及研究过程中的障碍。尽管存在这些挑战,但完成论文带来了许多专业或个人益处(成果)。
UIC的MHPE毕业生在硕士论文过程中存在多种成功因素和挑战。这些发现有助于学生通过硕士论文过程开展基于教育的学术研究。本研究还为项目评估和改进提供了参考,并概述了完成硕士论文的个人和职业成果。