De Bishnu P, Chen Alvin, Salami Christiana O, Van de Graaf Benjamin, Rosenberg Jonathan B, Pagovich Odelya E, Sondhi Dolan, Crystal Ronald G, Kaminsky Stephen M
Department of Genetic Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College , New York, New York.
Hum Gene Ther Methods. 2018 Jun;29(3):146-155. doi: 10.1089/hgtb.2017.246. Epub 2018 Jun 8.
The development of a drug product requires rigorous methods of characterization and quality control to assure drug potency. Gene therapy products, a relatively new strategy for drug design with very few licensed examples, represent a unique challenge for the measure of potency. Unlike traditional drugs, potency for a gene therapeutic is a tally of the measures of multiple steps, including infectivity, transcription, translation, protein modifications, proper localization of the protein product, and protein function. This is particularly challenging for products based on the adeno-associated virus (AAV) platform, which has poor in vitro infectivity, limiting the sensitivity and thus the usefulness of cell-based assays. A rigorous in vivo assay has been established that separately evaluates infection, transcription, and resulting protein levels with specifications for each based on real time polymerase chain reaction (DNA and RNA) and standard protein assays. For an acceptance criterion, an administered vector must have vector DNA, transgene mRNA, and transgene expressed protein each concurrently meet individual specifications or the production lot fails. Using the AAVrh.10 serotype as a model vector and three different transgenes as examples, the assay is based on intravenous administration of the vector to male mice. At 2 weeks, the harvested liver is homogenized and assessed for vector genome levels (to assess for vector delivery), mRNA (to assess vector infectivity and transcription), and protein in the liver or serum (to assess protein expression). For all AAV vectors, the assay is robust and reproducible: vector DNA (linearity 10-10 copies, coefficient of variation) intra-assay <0.8%, inter-assay <0.5%; mRNA intra-assay <3.3%, inter-assay <3.4%. The reproducibility of the assay for transgene expressed protein is product specific. This in vivo potency assay is a strategy for characterization and a quantitative lot release test, providing a path forward to meet regulatory drug requirements for any AAV gene therapy vectors.
药物产品的研发需要严格的表征方法和质量控制以确保药物效力。基因治疗产品作为一种相对较新的药物设计策略,获批的实例很少,其效力测定面临独特挑战。与传统药物不同,基因治疗药物的效力是多个步骤测定结果的总和,包括感染性、转录、翻译、蛋白质修饰、蛋白质产物的正确定位以及蛋白质功能。对于基于腺相关病毒(AAV)平台的产品而言,这一挑战尤为突出,因为其体外感染性较差,限制了基于细胞的检测方法的灵敏度及实用性。现已建立一种严格的体内检测方法,该方法基于实时聚合酶链反应(DNA和RNA)及标准蛋白质检测,分别评估感染、转录以及由此产生的蛋白质水平,并为每项设定规格。作为验收标准,所施用的载体必须使载体DNA、转基因mRNA和转基因表达的蛋白质同时满足各自的规格要求,否则该生产批次不合格。以AAVrh.10血清型作为模型载体,并以三种不同的转基因为例,该检测方法基于向雄性小鼠静脉内施用载体。在第2周时,采集肝脏并匀浆,评估载体基因组水平(以评估载体递送情况)、mRNA(以评估载体感染性和转录情况)以及肝脏或血清中的蛋白质(以评估蛋白质表达情况)。对于所有AAV载体,该检测方法稳健且可重复:载体DNA(线性范围10 - 10拷贝,变异系数)批内<0.8%,批间<0.5%;mRNA批内<3.3%,批间<3.4%。转基因表达蛋白质检测方法的可重复性因产品而异。这种体内效力检测方法是一种表征策略和定量放行检测方法,为满足任何AAV基因治疗载体的监管药物要求提供了一条途径。