Department of Gastroenterology and Alimentary Tract Surgery, Tampere University Hospital, Tampere, Finland.
Medicine, University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2018 Sep;72(9):803-808. doi: 10.1136/jech-2017-210187. Epub 2018 May 2.
Surgical resection is the best treatment option to improve the prognosis of pancreatic cancer (PC). Our aim was to analyse whether PC treatment strategies show regional variation in Finland, a country with a nationwide public healthcare system.
All patients diagnosed with PC in 2003 and 2008 were identified from the Finnish Cancer Registry. The data regarding tumour, treatment, demographics and timespans to treatment were recorded from the patient archives. Patients were included in the healthcare district where the diagnosis was made. The healthcare districts were classified according to experience in pancreatic surgery into three groups (high level of experience region (HLER), n=2; medium level of experience region (MLER), n=6, and low level of experience region (LLER), n=13).
Patients included numbered 1546 (median age 72 years (range 34-97), 45% men). Demographics and the ratio of stage IV disease (53%) were similar between the regional groups. Despite this, the proportion of radical surgery was greater in HLERs than in the MLERs and LLERs (18% vs 8%-11%; p<0.01). Logistic regression analysis including age, American Society of Anesthesiologists classification, stage and level of experience showed that more radical resections were performed in the HLERs. Preoperative bile drainage showed no regional differences (p=0.137). Palliative chemotherapy only was used more frequently in MLER and LLER than in HLERs (24% vs 33%-30%; p<0.01).
Access to PC curative treatment was more likely for patients in healthcare districts including a hospital with high level of experience in pancreatic surgery. This highlights the importance of centralized treatment guidance.
手术切除是改善胰腺癌(PC)预后的最佳治疗选择。我们的目的是分析在芬兰这样一个拥有全国性公共医疗体系的国家,PC 的治疗策略是否存在地域差异。
从芬兰癌症登记处确定了 2003 年和 2008 年诊断为 PC 的所有患者。从患者档案中记录了肿瘤、治疗、人口统计学以及治疗时间的相关数据。患者被纳入诊断所在的医疗保健区。根据胰腺手术经验,将医疗保健区分为三组(高水平经验区(HLER),n=2;中水平经验区(MLER),n=6,和低水平经验区(LLER),n=13)。
纳入的患者人数为 1546 名(中位年龄 72 岁(范围 34-97),45%为男性)。地域组之间的人口统计学和 IV 期疾病的比例(53%)相似。尽管如此,HLER 中根治性手术的比例高于 MLER 和 LLER(18%比 8%-11%;p<0.01)。包括年龄、美国麻醉医师协会分级、分期和经验水平的 logistic 回归分析显示,HLER 中进行了更多的根治性切除术。术前胆汁引流无地域差异(p=0.137)。与 HLER 相比,MLER 和 LLER 更频繁地使用姑息性化疗(24%比 33%-30%;p<0.01)。
在包括高水平胰腺手术经验的医院的医疗保健区,患者获得 PC 根治性治疗的机会更大。这凸显了集中治疗指导的重要性。