Auais Mohammad, French Simon D, Beaupre Lauren, Giangregorio Lora, Magaziner Jay
School of Rehabilitation Therapy, Queen's University, Kingston, ON, Canada.
School of Rehabilitation Therapy, Queen's University, Kingston, ON, Canada; Department of Chiropractic, Macquarie University, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Injury. 2018 Aug;49(8):1466-1472. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2018.04.017. Epub 2018 Apr 20.
Hip fractures rank in the top ten disabling conditions worldwide. With an ageing population, this public health problem is expected to increase. Despite the success of surgery for hip fractures and the extensive health services utilisation, health outcomes are often poor. Considering the recovery process as multifactorial and intervening to address all relevant factors may improve recovery rates. However, we need first to fully understand the factors contributing to recovery after hip fractures, including psycho-cognitive and social factors. The purpose of this study was to identify future research priorities for understanding the role of psycho-cognitive and social factors in the recovery process for community-dwelling older adults after hip fracture and to survey world experts to confirm the identified priorities.
This was a two-stage process. First, a workshop of international experts in hip fracture care (researchers and clinician-scientists) was held in 2016 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Using Nominal Group Technique accompanied by Multi-voting Technique, workshop attendees identified the most important future research areas for psycho-cognitive and social factors contributing to recovery after hip fractures. Second, an online survey of the International Fragility Fracture Network (FFN), which includes researchers and clinicians interested in fragility fractures, followed the meeting. The survey respondents reviewed and added to priorities from the first stage and then ranked the top priorities.
Twenty-three experts participated in the meeting (from five countries) and 152 participants (from 29 countries) responded to the survey. Top priorities for the psycho-cognitive domain were preventing and treating in-hospital delirium; comparing the effectiveness of targeted versus multifactorial interventions; studying interactions between psycho-cognitive, social, and environmental factors in the recovery process; and modifying the environment to enhance patients' cognitive reserves. Top priorities for the social domain were understanding the role of social factors in the recovery process; understanding patients' perspectives on important social factors; identifying components of social support relevant to recovery; understanding attitudes towards patients with hip fractures among all stakeholders; and understanding the social support needs for caregivers.
A set of future research priorities to understand the role of psycho-cognitive and social factors has been developed and confirmed through a rigorous international decision-making process. These priorities offer valuable guidance for researchers, scientific bodies, and funding agencies.
髋部骨折位列全球十大致残疾病。随着人口老龄化,这一公共卫生问题预计会加剧。尽管髋部骨折手术取得成功且卫生服务利用广泛,但健康结局往往不佳。鉴于恢复过程是多因素的,干预并解决所有相关因素可能会提高恢复率。然而,我们首先需要全面了解导致髋部骨折后恢复的因素,包括心理认知和社会因素。本研究的目的是确定未来研究重点,以了解心理认知和社会因素在社区居住的老年髋部骨折患者恢复过程中的作用,并调查全球专家以确认所确定的重点。
这是一个两阶段过程。首先,2016年在加拿大魁北克省蒙特利尔举行了一次髋部骨折护理国际专家(研究人员和临床科学家)研讨会。使用名义小组技术并辅以多轮投票技术,研讨会参与者确定了导致髋部骨折后恢复的心理认知和社会因素的最重要未来研究领域。其次,在会议之后对国际脆性骨折网络(FFN)进行了在线调查,该网络包括对脆性骨折感兴趣的研究人员和临床医生。调查受访者回顾并补充了第一阶段的重点,然后对首要重点进行了排序。
23名专家(来自5个国家)参加了会议,152名参与者(来自29个国家)回复了调查。心理认知领域的首要重点是预防和治疗住院期间的谵妄;比较针对性干预与多因素干预的效果;研究恢复过程中心理认知、社会和环境因素之间的相互作用;以及改善环境以增强患者的认知储备。社会领域的首要重点是了解社会因素在恢复过程中的作用;了解患者对重要社会因素的看法;确定与恢复相关的社会支持组成部分;了解所有利益相关者对髋部骨折患者的态度;以及了解护理人员的社会支持需求。
通过严格的国际决策过程,已制定并确认了一套未来研究重点,以了解心理认知和社会因素的作用。这些重点为研究人员、科学机构和资助机构提供了有价值的指导。