Tong Sebastian T, Liaw Winston R, Kashiri Paulette Lail, Pecsok James, Rozman Julia, Bazemore Andrew W, Krist Alex H
From Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA (STT, PLK, JP, JR, AWB, AHK); The Robert Graham Center, Washington D.C. (WRL, AWB), University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston (WRL).
J Am Board Fam Med. 2018 May-Jun;31(3):351-363. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2018.03.170419.
Despite clear evidence demonstrating the influence of social determinants on health, whether and how clinicians should address these determinants remain unclear. We aimed to understand primary care clinicians' experiences of administering a social needs screening instrument.
Using a prospective, observational design, we identified patients living in communities with lower education and income seen by 17 clinicians from 12 practices in northern Virginia. Before office visits, patients completed social needs surveys, which probed about their quality of life, education, housing, finances, substance use, transportation, social connections, physical activity, and food access. Clinicians then reviewed the completed surveys with patients. Concurrently, clinicians participated in a series of learning collaboratives to consider how to address social needs as part of care and completed diary entries about how knowing the patient's social needs influenced care after seeing each patient.
Out of a total of 123 patients, 106 (86%) reported a social need. Excluding physical activity, 71% reported a social need, although only 3% wanted help. Clinicians reported that knowing the patient had a social need changed care delivery in 23% of patients and helped improve interactions with and knowledge of the patient in 53%. Clinicians reported that assessing social needs is difficult and resource intensive and that there were insufficient resources to help patients with identified needs.
Clinicians reported that knowing patients' social needs changed what they did and improved communication for many patients. However, more evidence is needed regarding the benefit of social needs screening in primary care before widespread implementation.
尽管有明确证据表明社会决定因素对健康有影响,但临床医生是否以及应如何应对这些决定因素仍不明确。我们旨在了解基层医疗临床医生使用社会需求筛查工具的经历。
采用前瞻性观察设计,我们确定了弗吉尼亚州北部12家诊所的17名临床医生所诊治的生活在教育程度和收入较低社区的患者。在就诊前,患者完成社会需求调查,该调查涉及他们的生活质量、教育、住房、财务、物质使用、交通、社会关系、身体活动和食物获取情况。然后临床医生与患者一起回顾已完成的调查。同时,临床医生参加了一系列学习协作活动,以考虑如何将解决社会需求作为护理的一部分,并在看完每个患者后完成关于了解患者社会需求如何影响护理的日记记录。
在总共123名患者中,106名(86%)报告有社会需求。排除身体活动因素,71%的患者报告有社会需求,尽管只有3%的患者希望获得帮助。临床医生报告称,了解到患者有社会需求后,23%的患者的护理方式发生了改变,53%的患者的医患互动得到改善,临床医生对患者的了解也有所增加。临床医生报告称,评估社会需求既困难又耗费资源,而且没有足够的资源来帮助有明确需求的患者。
临床医生报告称,了解患者的社会需求改变了他们的行为,并改善了许多患者的沟通情况。然而,在广泛实施之前,还需要更多关于基层医疗中社会需求筛查益处的证据。