Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.
J Clin Nurs. 2018 Nov;27(21-22):3830-3845. doi: 10.1111/jocn.14534. Epub 2018 Jul 30.
To explore registered nurses', licensed practical nurses' and healthcare aides' perceptions of their own and each other's role contributions.
In response to contemporary economic and political pressures, healthcare institutions across the world have endeavoured to download job duties to less educated healthcare providers. As a result, nursing care is usually delivered by a team of nursing staff that have different roles. This means that there are fewer registered nurses and more licensed practical nurses and healthcare aides on nursing teams, despite evidence that increased numbers of registered nurses improve patient safety and care outcomes.
This study was an integrative review using Whittemore and Knafl's stages for ensuring rigour. These stages include problem identification, literature searching, data evaluation, data analysis and presentation.
Four electronic databases were searched according to previously designed search strategies. The 14 retrieved articles were appraised using MMATs for quality. Data were extracted and analysed thematically.
The findings of the integrative review revealed that registered nurses, licensed practical nurses and healthcare aides had little understanding about the roles of their fellow nursing team members and had difficulties describing their own roles. However, no studies concurrently examined registered nurses', licensed practical nurses' and healthcare aides' perceptions on their own or each other's roles and little were written about licensed practical nurses.
More research is needed to examine the entire nursing team's perceptions about the various nursing roles.
探索注册护士、执业护士和医疗保健助手对自身和彼此角色贡献的看法。
为应对当代经济和政治压力,全球各地的医疗机构都试图将工作职责下放到受教育程度较低的医疗保健提供者手中。因此,护理工作通常由一组具有不同角色的护理人员来完成。这意味着护理团队中的注册护士越来越少,而执业护士和医疗保健助手越来越多,尽管有证据表明增加注册护士的数量可以提高患者的安全性和护理效果。
本研究是一项综合审查,使用 Whittemore 和 Knafl 的方法确保严谨性。这些阶段包括问题识别、文献检索、数据评估、数据分析和呈现。
根据预先设计的搜索策略,对四个电子数据库进行了搜索。使用 MMATs 对检索到的 14 篇文章进行质量评估。提取数据并进行主题分析。
综合审查的结果表明,注册护士、执业护士和医疗保健助手对其同事的角色知之甚少,并且难以描述自己的角色。然而,没有研究同时检查注册护士、执业护士和医疗保健助手对自身或彼此角色的看法,而且关于执业护士的研究很少。
需要进一步研究,以检查整个护理团队对各种护理角色的看法。