Department of Chemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824-1322.
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry and STEM Transformation Institute, Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199-2516.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2018 Jun;17(2):ar33. doi: 10.1187/cbe.18-01-0004.
While many university students take science courses in multiple disciplines, little is known about how they perceive common concepts from different disciplinary perspectives. Structure-property and structure-function relationships have long been considered important explanatory concepts in the disciplines of chemistry and biology, respectively. Fourteen university students concurrently enrolled in introductory chemistry and biology courses were interviewed to explore their perceptions regarding 1) the meaning of structure, properties, and function; 2) the presentation of these concepts in their courses; and 3) how these concepts might be related. Findings suggest that the concepts of structure and properties were interpreted similarly between chemistry and biology, but students more closely associated the discussion of structure-property relationships with their chemistry courses and structure-function with biology. Despite receiving little in the way of instructional support, nine students proposed a coherent conceptual relationship, indicating that structure determines properties, which determine function. Furthermore, students described ways in which they connected and benefited from their understanding. Though many students are prepared to make these connections, we would encourage instructors to engage in cross-disciplinary conversations to understand the shared goals and disciplinary distinctions regarding these important concepts in an effort to better support students unable to construct these connections for themselves.
虽然许多大学生在多个学科领域学习科学课程,但对于他们如何从不同学科角度看待常见概念却知之甚少。结构-性质和结构-功能关系长期以来一直被认为是化学和生物学学科中重要的解释性概念。本研究采访了 14 名同时修读基础化学和生物学课程的大学生,以探讨他们对以下方面的看法:1)结构、性质和功能的含义;2)这些概念在课程中的呈现方式;3)这些概念可能存在怎样的联系。研究结果表明,化学和生物学对结构和性质的概念的解释相似,但学生更紧密地将结构-性质关系的讨论与他们的化学课程联系起来,将结构-功能与生物学联系起来。尽管学生很少得到教学支持,但有 9 名学生提出了一个连贯的概念关系,表明结构决定性质,性质决定功能。此外,学生还描述了他们如何建立联系并从中受益。尽管许多学生已经准备好建立这些联系,但我们鼓励教师进行跨学科对话,了解这些重要概念的共同目标和学科差异,以便更好地支持那些无法自行建立这些联系的学生。