Department of Psychology, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
Prev Med. 2018 Sep;114:1-17. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2018.05.023. Epub 2018 May 23.
Guidelines recommend that women take folic acid supplements in the preconception period to prevent neural tube defects (NTDs) in their offspring. Estimates of adherence to this recommendation across different countries worldwide have not been synthesized. Medline, CINAHL, and EMBASE were systematically searched to identify studies reporting the prevalence of preconception folic acid supplementation. Pooled prevalence estimates for each country (where data were available) were calculated; and differences based on demographic, methodological, and study quality characteristics were examined. Of 3372 titles and abstracts screened, 722 full-texts were reviewed and 105 articles that reported 106 estimates of preconception folic acid supplementation in 34 countries were included. Pooled prevalence estimates were 32-51% in North America, 9-78% in Europe, 21-46% in Asia, 4-34% in the Middle East, 32-39% in Australia/New Zealand, and 0% in Africa. No South American studies were identified. Higher supplementation prevalence was observed in studies that had more highly educated samples, were conducted in fertility clinics, and assessed folic acid use via self-report. Of note, only 32% and 28% of studies reported timing of folic acid use and adherence to folic acid, respectively. Preconception folic acid supplementation is highly variable worldwide and many women may not achieve sufficient folate levels to prevent NTDs. To better understand non-adherence, recommendations for future research include: more explicit reporting of methodology, more detailed assessment of folic acid use, assessment of variables potentially relevant to folic acid use, and surveillance of folic acid use in a greater diversity of countries, especially in the developing world.
指南建议女性在受孕前补充叶酸以预防子女神经管缺陷(NTD)。但全球不同国家对该建议的依从率尚未进行综合评估。我们系统性检索了 Medline、CINAHL 和 EMBASE 以识别报告受孕前叶酸补充流行率的研究。(如果数据可用),我们计算了每个国家的汇总流行率估计值;并根据人口统计学、方法学和研究质量特征来检查差异。在筛选出的 3372 篇标题和摘要中,有 722 篇全文进行了审查,其中有 105 篇文章报道了 34 个国家的 106 项受孕前叶酸补充估计值,被纳入研究。汇总流行率估计值在北美为 32-51%,在欧洲为 9-78%,在亚洲为 21-46%,在中东为 4-34%,在澳新地区为 32-39%,在非洲则为 0%。未发现南美研究。在样本受教育程度较高、在生育诊所进行、并通过自我报告评估叶酸使用的研究中,叶酸补充的流行率更高。值得注意的是,只有 32%和 28%的研究分别报告了叶酸使用的时间和叶酸的依从性。全球范围内,受孕前叶酸补充的情况差异很大,许多女性可能无法达到预防 NTD 的足够叶酸水平。为了更好地了解不依从的情况,对未来研究的建议包括:更明确地报告方法学,更详细地评估叶酸的使用,评估可能与叶酸使用相关的变量,以及在更多不同的国家,特别是在发展中国家,监测叶酸的使用情况。