a Educational Innovative Institute, Academic Affairs , Medical College of Georgia at Augusta University , Augusta , Georgia.
b Department of Medicine, Academic Affairs , Medical College of Georgia at Augusta University , Augusta , Georgia.
Med Educ Online. 2018 Dec;23(1):1474699. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2018.1474699.
Previous research on Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) programs as an early clinical experience indicates that medical students' confidence in patient care and team-building skills increases with participation. However, very little is known about the unplanned, long-term effects of EMT courses on medical students once they enter medical school.
This study examined the immediate outcomes produced by the month-long summer EMT course and the unplanned outcomes that students reported 1 year later.
Pre/postsurveys were collected on all 25 students who graduated from the EMT course offered before their first year. These survey data were analyzed using a paired-samples t test. A subset of students (N = 14) consented to taking a survey and be interviewed on the lasting impact of their EMT experience. Interviews were conducted 10 months after the 2016 cohort completed the EMT course and at 22 months for the 2015 cohort. They were audio-recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using inductive content analysis.
Survey results indicated that students' confidence in patient care and team-building skills increased significantly for all identified skills at the P < 0.05 level. Overall confidence in patient care increased 1.5 points (P = 0.001) on 1-4 Likert-type scale. Overall confidence in team-building skills increased at 0.7 points (P = 0.01). Qualitative analysis of interviews discovered four themes, including the retention and transferability of practical skills, a developed understanding of team communication, comfort with patient interactions, and the development of a framework for assessing patients' needs. Students applied the EMT skills in various extracurricular volunteering experiences and in clinical skills courses.
This study concludes that EMT programs have both immediate and lasting effects that seem to assist students with making sense of and navigating other learning opportunities. Specifically, EMT courses offered to students prior to their entry into medical school may help orient them to team-based health care and triaging patient care.
之前的研究表明, EMT 课程作为一种早期临床经验, EMT 课程可以提高医学生对患者护理和团队建设技能的信心。然而,对于医学生一旦进入医学院后, EMT 课程对他们的无计划的、长期影响却知之甚少。
本研究考察了为期一个月的暑期 EMT 课程带来的即时结果,以及学生在 1 年后报告的无计划结果。
对参加 EMT 课程的 25 名学生进行了预/后调查,这些学生都在他们的第一年之前毕业。使用配对样本 t 检验分析这些调查数据。从学生中随机抽取了一部分(n=14),同意在 EMT 经验的持久影响方面进行调查和访谈。对 2016 年 cohort 完成 EMT 课程后的 10 个月和 2015 年 cohort 的 22 个月进行了访谈。访谈采用录音、转录和归纳内容分析。
调查结果表明,在所有确定的技能方面,学生对患者护理和团队建设技能的信心都有显著提高, P<0.05。在 1-4 级 Likert 量表上,对患者护理的整体信心增加了 1.5 分(P=0.001)。团队建设技能的整体信心增加了 0.7 分(P=0.01)。对访谈的定性分析发现了四个主题,包括实践技能的保留和可转移性、对团队沟通的理解、与患者互动的舒适度,以及评估患者需求的框架的发展。学生将 EMT 技能应用于各种课外志愿活动和临床技能课程中。
本研究得出结论, EMT 课程既有即时影响,也有持久影响,似乎有助于学生理解和驾驭其他学习机会。具体来说,在医学生进入医学院之前为他们提供的 EMT 课程可能有助于他们适应以团队为基础的医疗保健和分诊患者护理。