Eastwood Kyle W, Bodani Vivek P, Haji Faizal A, Looi Thomas, Naguib Hani E, Drake James M
1Center for Image-Guided Innovation and Therapeutic Intervention, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto.
3Institute of Biomaterials and Biomedical Engineering, University of Toronto.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2018 Aug;22(2):128-136. doi: 10.3171/2018.2.PEDS18121. Epub 2018 Jun 1.
OBJECTIVE Endoscope-assisted repair of craniosynostosis is a safe and efficacious alternative to open techniques. However, this procedure is challenging to learn, and there is significant variation in both its execution and outcomes. Surgical simulators may allow trainees to learn and practice this procedure prior to operating on an actual patient. The purpose of this study was to develop a realistic, relatively inexpensive simulator for endoscope-assisted repair of metopic and sagittal craniosynostosis and to evaluate the models' fidelity and teaching content. METHODS Two separate, 3D-printed, plastic powder-based replica skulls exhibiting metopic (age 1 month) and sagittal (age 2 months) craniosynostosis were developed. These models were made into consumable skull "cartridges" that insert into a reusable base resembling an infant's head. Each cartridge consists of a multilayer scalp (skin, subcutaneous fat, galea, and periosteum); cranial bones with accurate landmarks; and the dura mater. Data related to model construction, use, and cost were collected. Eleven novice surgeons (residents), 9 experienced surgeons (fellows), and 5 expert surgeons (attendings) performed a simulated metopic and sagittal craniosynostosis repair using a neuroendoscope, high-speed drill, rongeurs, lighted retractors, and suction/irrigation. All participants completed a 13-item questionnaire (using 5-point Likert scales) to rate the realism and utility of the models for teaching endoscope-assisted strip suturectomy. RESULTS The simulators are compact, robust, and relatively inexpensive. They can be rapidly reset for repeated use and contain a minimal amount of consumable material while providing a realistic simulation experience. More than 80% of participants agreed or strongly agreed that the models' anatomical features, including surface anatomy, subgaleal and subperiosteal tissue planes, anterior fontanelle, and epidural spaces, were realistic and contained appropriate detail. More than 90% of participants indicated that handling the endoscope and the instruments was realistic, and also that the steps required to perform the procedure were representative of the steps required in real life. CONCLUSIONS Both the metopic and sagittal craniosynostosis simulators were developed using low-cost methods and were successfully designed to be reusable. The simulators were found to realistically represent the surgical procedure and can be used to develop the technical skills required for performing an endoscope-assisted craniosynostosis repair.
目的 内窥镜辅助修复颅缝早闭是一种安全有效的开放性技术替代方案。然而,该手术学习难度较大,其操作和结果存在显著差异。手术模拟器可让学员在对实际患者进行手术之前学习和练习该手术。本研究的目的是开发一种逼真且相对廉价的模拟器,用于内窥镜辅助修复额缝和矢状缝颅缝早闭,并评估模型的逼真度和教学内容。方法 开发了两个单独的基于塑料粉末的3D打印复制头骨,分别呈现额缝(1个月龄)和矢状缝(2个月龄)颅缝早闭。这些模型被制成可消耗的颅骨“盒”,插入类似婴儿头部的可重复使用底座中。每个盒由多层头皮(皮肤、皮下脂肪、帽状腱膜和骨膜)、带有精确标志点的颅骨以及硬脑膜组成。收集了与模型构建、使用和成本相关的数据。11名新手外科医生(住院医师)、9名经验丰富的外科医生(研究员)和5名专家外科医生(主治医师)使用神经内窥镜、高速钻、咬骨钳、照明牵开器和吸引/冲洗装置进行了模拟额缝和矢状缝颅缝早闭修复。所有参与者完成了一份13项问卷(使用5点李克特量表),以评估模型在教授内窥镜辅助条状缝切除术方面的逼真度和实用性。结果 模拟器结构紧凑、坚固且相对廉价。它们可以快速重置以便重复使用,包含的消耗材料最少,同时提供逼真的模拟体验。超过80%的参与者同意或强烈同意模型的解剖特征,包括表面解剖、帽状腱膜下和骨膜下组织平面、前囟和硬膜外间隙,是逼真的且细节适当。超过90%的参与者表示操作内窥镜和器械很逼真,并且执行该手术所需的步骤代表了现实生活中所需的步骤。结论 额缝和矢状缝颅缝早闭模拟器均采用低成本方法开发,成功设计为可重复使用。发现模拟器能逼真地呈现手术过程,可用于培养进行内窥镜辅助颅缝早闭修复所需的技术技能。