Thiong'o Grace M, Bernstein Mark, Drake James M
Center for Image Guided Innovation and Therapeutic Intervention, Toronto, Canada.
Division of Neurosurgery, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, 555 University Avenue, Ontario, M5G 1X8, Toronto, Canada.
3D Print Med. 2021 Mar 23;7(1):9. doi: 10.1186/s41205-021-00099-4.
The objectives of this manuscript were to review the literature concerning 3D printing of brain and cranial vault pathology and use these data to define the gaps in global utilization of 3D printing technology for neurosurgical education.
Using specified criteria, literature searching was conducted to identify publications describing engineered neurosurgical simulators. Included in the study were manuscripts highlighting designs validated for neurosurgical skill transfer. Purely anatomical designs, lacking aspects of surgical simulation, were excluded. Eligible manuscripts were analyzed. Data on the types of simulators, representing the various modelled neurosurgical pathologies, were recorded. Authors' countries of affiliation were also recorded.
A total of thirty-six articles, representing ten countries in five continents were identified. Geographically, Africa as a continent was not represented in any of the publications. The simulation-modelling encompassed a variety of neurosurgical subspecialties including: vascular, skull base, ventriculoscopy / ventriculostomy, craniosynostosis, skull lesions / skull defects, intrinsic brain tumor and other. Finally, the vascular and skull base categories together accounted for over half (52.8 %) of the 3D printed simulated neurosurgical pathology.
Despite the growing body of literature supporting 3D printing in neurosurgical education, its full potential has not been maximized. Unexplored areas of 3D printing for neurosurgical simulation include models simulating the resection of intrinsic brain tumors or of epilepsy surgery lesions, as these require complex models to accurately simulate fine dissection techniques. 3D printed surgical phantoms offer an avenue for the advancement of global-surgery education initiatives.
本论文的目的是回顾关于脑和颅穹窿病变3D打印的文献,并利用这些数据来界定3D打印技术在神经外科教育全球应用方面的差距。
使用特定标准进行文献检索,以识别描述工程化神经外科模拟器的出版物。纳入研究的是突出经验证可用于神经外科技能转移的设计的手稿。纯粹的解剖学设计,缺乏手术模拟方面的内容,被排除在外。对符合条件的手稿进行分析。记录代表各种模拟神经外科病变的模拟器类型的数据。还记录了作者的所属国家。
共识别出36篇文章,代表五大洲的10个国家。在地理上,非洲大陆在任何出版物中均未被代表。模拟建模涵盖了多种神经外科亚专业,包括:血管、颅底、脑室镜检查/脑室造瘘术、颅缝早闭、颅骨病变/颅骨缺损、脑内肿瘤及其他。最后,血管和颅底类别合计占3D打印模拟神经外科病变的一半以上(52.8%)。
尽管支持3D打印在神经外科教育中的文献不断增加,但其全部潜力尚未得到充分发挥。神经外科模拟3D打印的未探索领域包括模拟脑内肿瘤切除或癫痫手术病变切除的模型,因为这些需要复杂模型来准确模拟精细解剖技术。3D打印手术模型为全球外科教育倡议的推进提供了一条途径。