Hsu Daniel P, Hansen Shana L, Roberts Timothy A, Murray Clinton K, Mysliwiec Vincent
Department of Pediatrics, San Antonio Military Medical Center, 3551 Roger Brooke Drive, JBSA Fort Sam Houston, TX.
Department of Sleep Medicine, Wilford Hall Ambulatory Surgical Center, 2200 Bergquist Dr. Ste 1, JBSA Lackland AFB, TX.
Mil Med. 2018 Nov 1;183(11-12):e641-e648. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usy059.
In 2013, the U.S. Army Surgeon General implemented the Performance Triad (P3), an educational initiative to improve health-related behaviors of soldiers throughout the U.S. Army. The components of P3 are Sleep, Activity, and Nutrition with tenet behaviors for each component. This study reports the results of the 2015 U.S. Army Medical Corps survey regarding physician knowledge and adherence to the tenet behaviors of P3.
In 2015, an anonymous survey was sent to all active duty U.S. Army physicians to assess demographic information, work hours, and knowledge of and adherence to P3. The survey assessed the tenets of P3 with questions about the following topics: obtaining 8 h of sleep per day; performing at least 2 d of resistance training and 1 day of agility training per week; re-fueling 30-60 min after exercise; incorporating at least 150 min of moderate and 75 min of vigorous aerobic exercise per week; going caffeine free 6 h before bedtime; eating at least 8 servings of fruits and vegetables per day; and getting 15,000 steps per day. For each question, there were four response options which ranged from "Always" to "Never." A positive response to the questionnaire was defined as answering frequently or always. The responses were analyzed by comparison of several physician categories utilizing descriptive statistics and multivariable analysis.
Surveys were completed by 1,003 of approximately 4,500 U.S. Army physicians. 79.1% of the respondents were male. Staff physicians made up 834 (83.6%) of the respondents compared with 164 (16.4%) physicians in training. Overall 25% of respondents were adherent to the sleep tenet, 45% to the exercise tenet, and 38% to the nutrition tenet. Reported work hours were significantly higher in physicians in training compared with staff physicians (p < 0.001). About 28.4% of staff reported a positive response to obtaining at least 8 h of sleep per night, compared with 12.7% of residents/fellows. In multivariable analyses, better sleep was associated with being a staff physician [odds ratio 2.4 (95% confidence interval 1.40-4.13)], working fewer hours per week [1.75 (1.37-2.25)], and belief in supervisor adherence to P3 [2.04 (1.59-2.56)]. Increased exercise was associated with male gender [2.09 (1.45-3.02)], being a staff physician [1.63 (1.09-2.43)], and belief in supervisor adherence to P3 [1.43 (1.18-1.75)]. Positive response to the nutrition tenet was associated with belief in supervisor adherence to P3 [1.23 (1.01-1.49)].
Overall, U.S. Army physicians are most adherent to the exercise tenet and least adherent to the sleep tenet of P3; this is consistent with the military culture. Work hours seem to affect wellness behaviors. Specifically, physicians who work fewer hours are more likely to report obtaining 8 h of sleep per day and exercise on a regular basis. Importantly, belief in supervisor adherence to P3 was associated with better adherence to P3, suggesting that physician leadership has a positive effect on wellness behaviors. This suggests a role for similar wellness programs in civilian healthcare institutions. Future research should also include changes in health system policies to motivate physician wellness behaviors.
2013年,美国陆军军医局局长实施了“绩效三联体”(P3),这是一项旨在改善美国陆军全体士兵与健康相关行为的教育倡议。P3的组成部分包括睡眠、活动和营养,每个组成部分都有相应的原则性行为。本研究报告了2015年美国陆军医疗队关于医生对P3原则性行为的知晓和遵守情况的调查结果。
2015年,向所有现役美国陆军医生发送了一份匿名调查问卷,以评估人口统计学信息、工作时间以及对P3的知晓和遵守情况。该调查通过以下主题的问题评估P3的原则:每天获得8小时睡眠;每周至少进行2天的抗阻训练和1天的敏捷训练;运动后30 - 60分钟补充能量;每周至少进行150分钟的中等强度有氧运动和75分钟的剧烈有氧运动;睡前6小时不摄入咖啡因;每天至少食用8份水果和蔬菜;每天走15000步。对于每个问题,有四个回答选项,范围从“总是”到“从不”。对问卷的肯定回答定义为经常或总是回答。通过使用描述性统计和多变量分析对几个医生类别进行比较来分析回答情况。
约4500名美国陆军医生中有1003人完成了调查。79.1%的受访者为男性。主治医师占受访者的834人(83.6%),相比之下,培训中的医生有164人(16.4%)。总体而言,25%的受访者遵守睡眠原则,45%遵守运动原则,38%遵守营养原则。培训中的医生报告的工作时间明显高于主治医师(p < 0.001)。约28.4%的主治医师报告对每晚至少获得8小时睡眠的回答为肯定,而住院医师/研究员中这一比例为12.7%。在多变量分析中,更好的睡眠与为主治医师[优势比2.4(95%置信区间1.40 - 4.13)]、每周工作时间较少[1.75(1.37 - 2.25)]以及相信上级遵守P3[2.04(1.59 - 2.56)]相关。运动增加与男性性别[2.09(1.45 - 3.02)]、为主治医师[1.63(1.09 - 2.43)]以及相信上级遵守P3[1.