Brandt Thomas, Grill Eva, Strupp Michael, Huppert Doreen
German Center for Vertigo and Balance Disorders, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, University Hospital, Munich, Germany.
Institute for Clinical Neurosciences, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, University Hospital, Munich, Germany.
Front Neurol. 2018 Jun 6;9:406. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2018.00406. eCollection 2018.
To determine the susceptibility to visual height intolerance (vHI) in patients with acquired bilateral vestibulopathy (BVP). The question was whether postural instability in BVP, which is partially compensated for by visual substitution of the impaired vestibular control of balance, leads to an increased susceptibility. This is of particular importance since fear of heights is dependent on body posture, and visual control of balance at heights can no longer substitute vestibular input. For comparison susceptibility to vHI was determined in patients with other vestibular or functional disorders. A total of 150 patients aged 18 or above who had been referred to the German Center for Vertigo and Balance Disorders and diagnosed to have BVP were surveyed with a standardized questionnaire by specifically trained neurological professionals. Further, 481 patients with other vestibular or functional disorders were included. Susceptibility to vHI was reported by 29% (32 % in females, 25% in males) of the patients with BVP. Patients with vHI were slightly younger (67 vs. 71 years). Seventy percent of those with vHI reported avoidance of climbing, hiking, stairs, darkness, cycling or swimming (84% of those without vHI). Mean age for onset of vHI was 40 years. Susceptibility to vHI was higher in patients with other vertigo disorders than in those with BVP: 64% in those with phobic postural vertigo, 61% in vestibular migraine, 56% in vestibular paroxysmia, 54% in benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, 49% in unilateral vestibulopathy and 48% in Menière's disease. The susceptibility to vHI in BVP was not higher than that of the general population (28%).This allows two explanations that need not be alternatives but contribute to each other: (1) Patients with a bilateral peripheral vestibular deficit largely avoid exposure to heights because of their postural instability. (2) The irrational anxiety to fall from heights triggers increased susceptibility to vHI, not the objective postural instability. However, patients with BVP do not exhibit increased comorbid anxiety disorders. This view is supported by the significantly increased susceptibility to vHI in other vestibular syndromes, which are characterized by an increased comorbidity of anxiety disorders.
确定获得性双侧前庭病变(BVP)患者对视觉性恐高症(vHI)的易感性。问题在于,BVP患者的姿势不稳在一定程度上通过视觉替代受损的前庭平衡控制得以代偿,这种情况是否会导致易感性增加。这一点尤为重要,因为恐高取决于身体姿势,而高处的视觉平衡控制无法再替代前庭输入。为作比较,还测定了其他前庭或功能性疾病患者对vHI的易感性。共有150名年龄在18岁及以上、被转诊至德国眩晕与平衡障碍中心并被诊断为BVP的患者,由经过专门培训的神经科专业人员使用标准化问卷进行调查。此外,还纳入了481名患有其他前庭或功能性疾病的患者。BVP患者中有29%(女性为32%,男性为25%)报告有vHI易感性。有vHI的患者年龄稍小(67岁对71岁)。70%有vHI的患者报告避免攀爬、徒步旅行、爬楼梯、身处黑暗环境、骑自行车或游泳(无vHI的患者中这一比例为84%)。vHI的平均发病年龄为40岁。其他眩晕疾病患者对vHI的易感性高于BVP患者:恐惧姿势性眩晕患者中为64%,前庭性偏头痛患者中为61%,前庭阵发性眩晕患者中为56%,良性阵发性位置性眩晕患者中为54%,单侧前庭病变患者中为49%,梅尼埃病患者中为48%。BVP患者对vHI的易感性并不高于普通人群(28%)。这可以有两种解释,这两种解释并非相互排斥而是相互补充:(1)双侧外周前庭功能减退的患者由于姿势不稳,很大程度上避免暴露于高处。(2)对从高处坠落的非理性焦虑引发了对vHI的易感性增加,而非客观的姿势不稳。然而,BVP患者并未表现出共病焦虑症增加。这一观点得到了其他前庭综合征中vHI易感性显著增加的支持,这些综合征的特点是焦虑症共病增加。