Ravaldi Claudia, Levi Miriam, Angeli Elena, Romeo Gianpaolo, Biffino Marco, Bonaiuti Roberto, Vannacci Alfredo
CiaoLapo Onlus, Charity for Stillbirth and Perinatal Grief Support, Prato, Italy; International Stillbirth Alliance, Bristol, UK.
CeRIMP-Regional Centre for Occupational Diseases and Injuries, Tuscany Region, Florence, Italy.
Midwifery. 2018 Sep;64:53-59. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2018.05.008. Epub 2018 Jun 7.
To assess current practices of health care providers (HCPs) caring for women experiencing a stillbirth and to explore their needs for training to better support bereaved families.
Nationwide cross-sectional survey. The main outcome measures were the evaluation of HCPs cognition, emotions and behaviours with regard to the care of women with a stillbirth care, as well as their compliance with international guidelines.
750 HCPs, in 11 Italian hospitals, were administered a multiple-choice questionnaire.
The response rate was 89.9%; the majority (94.1%) were female, with a mean age of 37.6 (SD = 10.4) years. Midwives were the most represented (72.8%). Half of the respondents recommended immediate birth; only 55% routinely bathed and dressed stillborn babies for their parents to see, while 44.4% of HCPs immediately took the babies away without allowing parents to properly say goodbye to them. More than half felt inadequate and some even reported having failed to provide support to the family when caring for a woman with stillbirth in the past. The need for professional training courses was expressed by 90.2%, and three-quarters had never previously attended a course on perinatal bereavement care. When answers by Italian HCPs are systematically evaluated with reference to international guidelines, the results were very poor with only 27.9% of respondents reported having created memories of the baby and less than 3% complied with all recommendations in the areas of respect for baby and parents, appropriate birth options, and aftercare.
There is a substantial gap between the standards of care defined by international guidelines and the practices currently in place in Italy. Italian HCPs feel an urgent need to be offered professional training courses to better meet the needs of grieving families.
Perinatal HCPs should be aware of their pivotal role in helping bereaved parents after stillbirth and perinatal loss, and seek appropriate training.
评估为死产妇女提供护理的医护人员(HCPs)的当前做法,并探讨他们对培训的需求,以便更好地支持丧亲家庭。
全国性横断面调查。主要结局指标是对医护人员在死产护理方面的认知、情感和行为进行评估,以及他们对国际指南的遵循情况。
意大利11家医院的750名医护人员接受了多项选择题问卷调查。
回复率为89.9%;大多数(94.1%)为女性,平均年龄为37.6(标准差=10.4)岁。助产士占比最高(72.8%)。一半的受访者建议立即分娩;只有55%的人会常规地为死产婴儿洗澡和穿衣,以便其父母查看,而44.4%的医护人员会立即将婴儿带走,不让父母与他们好好道别。超过一半的人觉得自己能力不足,有些人甚至报告说过去在照顾死产妇女时未能为其家庭提供支持。90.2%的人表示需要专业培训课程,四分之三的人此前从未参加过围产期丧亲护理课程。当参照国际指南对意大利医护人员的回答进行系统评估时,结果非常糟糕,只有27.9%的受访者报告说为婴儿留存了纪念,在尊重婴儿和父母、适当的分娩选择及后续护理等方面,只有不到3%的人完全符合所有建议。
国际指南所定义的护理标准与意大利目前的实际做法之间存在很大差距。意大利医护人员迫切需要接受专业培训课程,以更好地满足悲伤家庭的需求。
围产期医护人员应意识到自己在帮助死产和围产期丧亲父母方面的关键作用,并寻求适当的培训。