Dell Pediatric Research Institute, Departments of Pediatrics, Nutrition, and Chemistry, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX.
Division of Nutritional Sciences and Department of Food Science, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
Am J Clin Nutr. 2018 Aug 1;108(2):211-227. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/nqy089.
Fatty acids are among the most studied nutrients in human metabolism and health. Endogenous fatty acid status influences health and disease via multiple mechanisms at all stages of the life cycle. Despite widespread interest, attempts to summarize the results of multiple studies addressing similar fatty acid-related outcomes via meta-analyses and systematic reviews have been disappointing, largely because of heterogeneity in study design, sampling, and laboratory and data analyses. Our purpose is to recommend best practices for fatty acid clinical nutrition and medical studies. Key issues in study design include judicious choice of sampled endogenous pools for fatty acid analysis, considering relevant physiologic state, duration of intervention and/or observation, consideration of specific fatty acid dynamics to link intake and endogenous concentrations, and interpretation of results with respect to known fatty acid ranges. Key laboratory considerations include proper sample storage, use of sample preparation methods known to be fit-for-purpose via published validation studies, detailed reporting or methods to establish proper fatty acid identification, and quantitative analysis, including calibration of differential response, quality control procedures, and reporting of data on a minimal set of fatty acids to enable comprehensive interpretation. We present a checklist of recommendations for fatty acid best practices to facilitate design, review, and evaluation of studies with the intention of improving study reproducibility.
脂肪酸是人类代谢和健康研究中最受关注的营养素之一。内源性脂肪酸状况通过生命周期各个阶段的多种机制影响健康和疾病。尽管人们对此广泛关注,但通过荟萃分析和系统评价来总结针对类似脂肪酸相关结局的多项研究结果的尝试令人失望,主要原因是研究设计、采样以及实验室和数据分析存在异质性。我们的目的是为脂肪酸临床营养和医学研究推荐最佳实践。研究设计中的关键问题包括明智地选择用于脂肪酸分析的内源性样本池,考虑相关的生理状态、干预和/或观察的持续时间、考虑特定的脂肪酸动态,以将摄入量与内源性浓度联系起来,以及根据已知的脂肪酸范围解释结果。关键的实验室考虑因素包括适当的样本储存、使用通过已发表的验证研究证明适合目的的样本制备方法、详细报告或方法以建立适当的脂肪酸鉴定和定量分析,包括差异响应的校准、质量控制程序以及报告一组最小的脂肪酸数据,以实现全面解释。我们提出了一份脂肪酸最佳实践建议清单,以促进研究的设计、审查和评估,旨在提高研究的可重复性。