Sharif Salman, Afsar Afifa
Department of Neurosurgery, Liaquat National Hospital and Medical College, Institute of Postgraduate Studies and Medical Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan.
Department of Neurosurgery, Liaquat National Hospital and Medical College, Institute of Postgraduate Studies and Medical Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan.
World Neurosurg. 2018 Nov;119:472-478. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2018.06.094. Epub 2018 Jun 20.
Minimally invasive surgery has become popular in recent times and has proved more advantageous than conventional open surgery methods, in terms of maximal preservation of natural anatomy and minimal postoperative complications. However, these advancements require a longer learning curve for inexperienced surgeons.
The learning curve in minimally invasive spine surgery is complex and difficult to measure, and therefore operating times, conversion to open procedures, visual analog scale, and periods of hospital stay are used. In assessing complications as a measure of the learning curve, it was noted that nearly all the complications had been documented previously and became minimum after the 30th consecutive case. As surgical experience increases, perioperative parameters (e.g., operative time and length of hospitalization) improve. The downside of minimally invasive spine surgery is starting unfamiliar procedures without tactile sensation, working in a narrow restricted surgical field, and using endoscopes via two-dimensional imaging.
Appropriate instruments, a trained team, and an adept radiographer are important assets for a smooth transition during the learning period. Structured training with cadavers and lots of practice, preferably while working under the guidance of experienced surgeons, is helpful. The learning curve can be shortened when a proficient surgeon gains relevant knowledge, understands three-dimensional anatomy, and has surgical aptitude along with manual dexterity.
近年来,微创手术已变得很普遍,并且在最大程度保留自然解剖结构和使术后并发症最少方面,已证明比传统的开放手术方法更具优势。然而,对于缺乏经验的外科医生而言,这些进展需要更长的学习曲线。
微创脊柱手术的学习曲线复杂且难以衡量,因此采用手术时间、转为开放手术的比例、视觉模拟评分以及住院时间来衡量。在将并发症作为学习曲线的一项衡量指标进行评估时,发现几乎所有并发症此前都有记录,并且在连续第30例手术后降至最低。随着手术经验的增加,围手术期参数(如手术时间和住院时长)会得到改善。微创脊柱手术的不利之处在于开始进行不熟悉的手术时缺乏触觉,在狭窄受限的手术视野中操作,以及通过二维成像使用内窥镜。
合适的器械、训练有素的团队以及熟练的放射技师是学习期间顺利过渡的重要条件。使用尸体进行结构化训练并大量练习,最好是在经验丰富的外科医生指导下进行,会有所帮助。当熟练的外科医生掌握相关知识、理解三维解剖结构并且具备手术能力以及手部灵活性时,学习曲线可以缩短。