Zadvinskis Inga M, Garvey Smith Jessica, Yen Po-Yin
Riverside Methodist Hospital, OhioHealth, Columbus, OH, United States.
Helene Fuld Health Trust National Institute for Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing and Healthcare, College of Nursing, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States.
JMIR Med Inform. 2018 Jun 26;6(2):e38. doi: 10.2196/medinform.8734.
Nurses are the largest group of health information technology (HIT) users. As such, nurses' adaptations are critical for HIT implementation success. However, longitudinal approaches to understanding nurses' perceptions of HIT remain underexplored. Previous studies of nurses' perceptions demonstrate that the progress and timing for acceptance of and adaptation to HIT varies.
This study aimed to explore nurses' experience regarding implementation of HIT over time.
A phenomenological approach was used for this longitudinal qualitative study to explore nurses' perceptions of HIT implementation over time, focusing on three time points (rounds) at 3, 9, and 18 months after implementation of electronic health records and bar code medication administration. The purposive sample was comprised of clinical nurses who worked on a medical-surgical unit in an academic center.
Major findings were categorized into 7 main themes with 54 subthemes. Nurses reported personal-level and organizational-level factors that facilitated HIT adaptation. We also generated network graphs to illustrate the occurrence of themes. Thematic interconnectivity differed due to nurses' concerns and satisfaction at different time points. Equipment and workflow were the most frequent themes across all three rounds. Nurses were the most dissatisfied approximately 9 months after HIT implementation. Eighteen months after HIT implementation, nurses' perceptions appeared more balanced.
It is recommended that organizations invest in equipment (ie, wireless barcode scanners), refine policies to reflect nursing practice, and improve systems to focus on patient safety. Future research is necessary to confirm patterns of nurses' adaptation to HIT in other samples.
护士是健康信息技术(HIT)的最大用户群体。因此,护士的适应对于HIT实施的成功至关重要。然而,了解护士对HIT看法的纵向研究方法仍未得到充分探索。先前关于护士看法的研究表明,接受和适应HIT的进展和时机各不相同。
本研究旨在探讨护士在一段时间内实施HIT的经历。
本纵向定性研究采用现象学方法,以探讨护士在一段时间内对HIT实施的看法,重点关注电子健康记录和条形码药物管理实施后3个月、9个月和18个月这三个时间点(轮次)。目的样本由在学术中心内科手术科室工作的临床护士组成。
主要发现分为7个主要主题和54个子主题。护士报告了促进HIT适应的个人层面和组织层面因素。我们还生成了网络图来说明主题的出现情况。由于护士在不同时间点的担忧和满意度不同,主题的相互关联性也有所不同。设备和工作流程是所有三轮中最常见的主题。在HIT实施约9个月后,护士的不满程度最高。在HIT实施18个月后,护士的看法似乎更加平衡。
建议组织投资设备(即无线条形码扫描仪),完善政策以反映护理实践,并改进系统以关注患者安全。有必要进行未来研究以确认其他样本中护士对HIT的适应模式。