Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resource Research, Beijing, 100101, China.
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 10080, China.
Environ Geochem Health. 2018 Dec;40(6):2667-2683. doi: 10.1007/s10653-018-0131-y. Epub 2018 Jun 14.
This study probe the human health risk of fluoride (F), arsenic (As), and selenium (Se) and their daily intake available quantity to human through different sources in different regions of Shaanxi, China. For this purpose, a number of samples, including coal and coal wastes, rocks, soil, and vegetables were collected from south Qinling Mountain stone-like coal (Geo type-I), Binxian-Jurassic (Geo type-II), Hancheng Permo-Carboniferous (Geo type-III), and countryside (Huanglong County) of Shaanxi province. All these samples were analyzed through atomic fluorescence spectroscopy and combustion hydrolysis methods. Results showed that Geo type-I was enriched with As, Se, and F, Geo type-II, III, and the countryside were slightly enriched with As and F and deficient in Se. The average daily intake (ADI) of Se in Geo type-I was 0.005-0.0045, Geo type-II 0.0005-0.0004, Geo type-III 0.0006-0.0005, and countryside 0.0002-0.001 in mg kg day adult-children, respectively, which was lower than the optimum level (0.06-0.075 mg kgday). ADI of As at Geo type-I was 0.0085-0.0075, Geo type-II 0.004-0.0037, Geo type-III 0.0008, and countryside 0.00022-0.00019 in mg kg day adult-children, respectively, which was above the acceptable range (10-10). ADI of F at Geo type-I was 0.0047-0.0041, Geo type-II 0.0098-0.0087, Geo type-III 0.002-0.0017 and countryside 0.0015-0.0013 in mg kg day adult-children, respectively. The toxicity level of Se and F at all the regions was lower than the NOAEL and LOAEL, while As was higher at Geo type-II and I. The extreme deficient of Se than the optimum range along with high F could deregulate the normal body growth especially causes bones and joint problems. However, the study found a rare patient with bone and joint disease (maybe Kashin-Beck disease) in the countryside. To find the exact cause of Kashin-Beck disease, the study needs further medical investigation in Se-deficient regions and their association with selenium deficiency and enriched fluoride.
本研究探讨了氟(F)、砷(As)和硒(Se)对人体的健康风险,以及它们通过中国陕西不同地区不同来源进入人体的每日可摄入量。为此,采集了来自秦岭石煤(地质类型 I)、宾县侏罗纪(地质类型 II)、韩城石炭二叠纪(地质类型 III)和陕西黄陵县农村地区的煤和煤渣、岩石、土壤和蔬菜等多种样本。所有这些样本均采用原子荧光光谱法和燃烧水解法进行分析。结果表明,地质类型 I 中 As、Se 和 F 含量较高,地质类型 II、III 和农村地区 As 和 F 含量略高,而 Se 含量较低。地质类型 I 中成人和儿童的每日硒摄入量(ADI)分别为 0.005-0.0045、0.0005-0.0004、0.0006-0.0005 和 0.0002-0.001,低于最佳水平(0.06-0.075mgkgday)。地质类型 I 中成人和儿童的砷 ADI 分别为 0.0085-0.0075、0.004-0.0037、0.0008 和 0.00022-0.00019,高于可接受范围(10-10)。地质类型 I 中氟的 ADI 分别为 0.0047-0.0041、0.0098-0.0087、0.002-0.0017 和 0.0015-0.0013,低于最佳水平。所有地区的 Se 和 F 的毒性水平均低于 NOAEL 和 LOAEL,而地质类型 II 和 I 中的 As 水平较高。硒在最佳范围内的极度缺乏以及高氟可能会扰乱正常的身体生长,特别是会导致骨骼和关节问题。然而,研究在农村地区发现了一例罕见的骨骼和关节疾病(可能是大骨节病)患者。为了找到大骨节病的确切病因,需要在缺硒地区进一步进行医学调查,并研究其与硒缺乏和富氟之间的关系。