Department of Women and Children's Health, Institute of Translational Medicine, University of Liverpool, Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
Department of Public Health, School of Public Health and Family Medicine University of Malawi, Blantyre, Malawi.
PLoS One. 2018 Jun 27;13(6):e0199757. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0199757. eCollection 2018.
Universal access to quality early childhood development and care is a fundamental part of Sustainable Development Goal 4.2.1. Research from diverse settings, including that in low and middle income countries, now demonstrates the positive impact that interventions to promote play, stimulation, early communication and responsiveness can have, not just on child development, but on long term gains in education and economic growth. International agencies have recently produced the Nurturing Care Framework for Early Child Development in order to promote this and to encourage countries to move the focus from child survival to child thrival. Research on the best methods of integration of these programmes into present care practices, particularly in African settings is still very limited.
We used qualitative methods to gain an understanding of care practices (play, developmental stimulation, early communication and responsive feeding) for children 0-2 years. We conducted 18 focus groups (FGDs), six PFGDs (Participatory Research focus groups), 18 in depth interviews (IDIs) and 20 observations with caregivers in rural and urban settings of Malawi. We used a topic guide, audio-recorded the FGDs and IDIS and transcribed them in Chichewa or Yao and then into English. We coded data using an inductive approach to thematic analysis. We placed the data within a framework with the emerging major and minor themes. We conducted quality assurance for translations and coding frameworks through cross comparison of data and used respondent validation to check our results.
Malawian caregivers see children's play as a consequence of good health and wellbeing, less an interaction that a parent undertakes to promote wellbeing and learning. Non-verbal communication and responsiveness with infants is clearly present and caregivers have many one-on-one interactions with young infants. Furthermore, many caregivers have good knowledge of feeding recommendations but cannot always follow these due to constraints on money. When children become mobile (toddlers), play is an activity done more often between children or with other caregivers such as siblings or grandparents. Community members consider that caring for children from 0-2 years is a woman's domain. Despite this, both men and women acknowledge the importance of maternal wellbeing in enabling good care of children. The present socioeconomic situation of most families in our study means that income generation and food security come first. Many mothers spend most of their time managing the responsibilities of daily living and have limited time to dedicate to children's play, responsiveness and communication with their children.
Programmes promoted as part of the Nurturing Care Framework which provide advice on developmental stimulation, play, early communication and responsive feeding should ensure that topics within these programmes are culturally appropriate for the setting. Furthermore, programmes must not be an added burden to parents but be supportive to parents managing many responsibilities of daily living. Multi-sectorial approaches where both men and women are provided with knowledge but are also supported through programmes which address family finances, safe spaces for children whilst families are working, and family mental health and relationships may enable programmes to work more effectively.
普及优质的儿童早期发展和照护是可持续发展目标 4.2.1 的一个基本组成部分。来自不同背景的研究,包括来自中低收入国家的研究,现在证明了促进游戏、刺激、早期沟通和回应能力的干预措施不仅对儿童发展有积极影响,而且对教育和经济增长的长期收益也有积极影响。国际机构最近制定了儿童早期发展培育护理框架,以促进这一点,并鼓励各国将重点从儿童生存转移到儿童茁壮成长。关于将这些方案最佳地融入现有照护实践的研究,特别是在非洲环境中,仍然非常有限。
我们使用定性方法来了解 0-2 岁儿童的照护实践(游戏、发育刺激、早期沟通和响应式喂养)。我们在马拉维的农村和城市环境中进行了 18 个焦点小组(FGD)、6 个参与式研究焦点小组(PFGD)、18 个深度访谈(IDI)和 20 次观察。我们使用了一个主题指南,对 FGD 和 IDI 进行了音频记录,并将其翻译成奇切瓦语或尧语,然后再翻译成英语。我们使用归纳方法对主题分析进行了编码。我们将数据放置在一个框架内,其中包含主要和次要主题。我们通过数据的交叉比较和受访者验证来检查结果,以确保翻译和编码框架的质量保证。
马拉维的照护者认为儿童的游戏是健康和幸福的结果,而不是父母为促进健康和学习而进行的互动。非语言交流和对婴儿的回应显然存在,照护者与幼儿有很多一对一的互动。此外,许多照护者对喂养建议有很好的了解,但由于资金限制,他们不能总是遵循这些建议。当孩子变得活跃(学步儿)时,游戏是孩子之间或与其他照护者(如兄弟姐妹或祖父母)之间进行的活动。社区成员认为,照顾 0-2 岁的儿童是女性的领域。尽管如此,男性和女性都承认母亲的幸福感对照顾好孩子的重要性。我们研究中的大多数家庭目前的社会经济状况意味着,创造收入和保障粮食安全是首要任务。许多母亲大部分时间都在管理日常生活的责任,几乎没有时间花在孩子的游戏、回应和与孩子的沟通上。
作为培育护理框架的一部分推广的方案,提供了关于发育刺激、游戏、早期沟通和响应式喂养的建议,应确保这些方案中的主题在文化上适合该环境。此外,方案不应成为父母的额外负担,而应支持父母管理日常生活中的许多责任。多部门办法可以让男性和女性都获得知识,但也要通过解决家庭财务、家庭工作时儿童的安全空间、家庭心理健康和关系等问题的方案来支持他们,这可能使方案更有效地发挥作用。