Muzaffar Henna, Metcalfe Jessica J, Fiese Barbara
Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, IL.
Family Resiliency Center, Urbana, IL.
Curr Dev Nutr. 2018 Apr 26;2(6):nzy016. doi: 10.1093/cdn/nzy016. eCollection 2018 Jun.
Policymakers, scientists, and food and nutrition practitioners suggest that there is a societal decline in culinary skills, which is predictive of poor dietary habits contributing to childhood obesity. A narrative review was conducted to critically evaluate culinary skill interventions for children ages 5-12 y in schools to identify specific programs and programmatic factors associated with improvement in the quality of diet, body mass index (BMI), and positive changes in psychosocial variables. The culinary interventions were implemented in urban and rural areas in the United States, Australia, and England. PubMed and Medline, the Cochrane database, and a hand-search of publications identified 131 articles; 6 articles were selected for further examination on the basis of the inclusion criteria. Study designs included 1 randomized controlled trial and 5 quasi-experimental studies. Three interventions were grounded in behavioral theory, of which 2 incorporated the Social Cognitive Theory framework. The target population and setting included children and early adolescents in schools. The study methodology primarily included cooking classes combined with nutrition education lessons, parent and community components, gardening classes, tasting sessions, school lunchroom components, trips to a farmers market, or visits to a restaurant. Qualitative evaluations of the programs indicated positive findings in terms of program appeal and improvement in cooking skills and healthy eating. Quantitative analysis indicated improvement in food preferences, cooking skills, cooking self-efficacy, cooking behavioral intentions, food-preparation frequency, knowledge, healthy dietary intake, BMI, and blood pressure. The findings from this review support a positive relation between culinary interventions with children in schools and improvement in cooking skills, consumption of a healthy diet, and positive changes in anthropometric assessments. This review also suggests that integration with the academic curriculum and school lunch program may be potential avenues to explore for improving the longevity and success of the cooking programs. Further research should emphasize rigorous methodologic standards, develop theory-based standardized frameworks, and evaluate long-term effects of culinary interventions.
政策制定者、科学家以及食品与营养从业者指出,社会的烹饪技能在下降,这预示着不良饮食习惯的出现,进而导致儿童肥胖。开展了一项叙述性综述,以严格评估针对5至12岁儿童在学校进行的烹饪技能干预措施,从而确定与饮食质量改善、体重指数(BMI)以及心理社会变量的积极变化相关的具体项目和项目因素。烹饪干预措施在美国、澳大利亚和英国的城市和农村地区实施。通过PubMed和Medline、Cochrane数据库以及手动检索出版物,共识别出131篇文章;根据纳入标准,挑选了6篇文章进行进一步审查。研究设计包括1项随机对照试验和5项准实验研究。三项干预措施以行为理论为基础,其中两项纳入了社会认知理论框架。目标人群和环境包括学校中的儿童和青少年早期。研究方法主要包括烹饪课程与营养教育课程相结合、家长和社区部分、园艺课程、品尝活动、学校食堂部分、前往农贸市场的实地考察或参观餐厅。对这些项目的定性评估表明,在项目吸引力、烹饪技能提高和健康饮食方面有积极成果。定量分析表明,在食物偏好、烹饪技能、烹饪自我效能感、烹饪行为意图、食物准备频率、知识、健康饮食摄入量、BMI和血压方面有所改善。该综述的结果支持学校针对儿童的烹饪干预措施与烹饪技能提高、健康饮食消费以及人体测量评估的积极变化之间存在正相关关系。该综述还表明,与学术课程和学校午餐计划相结合可能是探索提高烹饪项目的持续性和成功率的潜在途径。进一步的研究应强调严格的方法学标准,制定基于理论的标准化框架,并评估烹饪干预措施的长期效果。