Ihde Stefan, Palka Lukas, Gaur Vivek, Ihde Antonina
Evidence and Research Department, International Implant Foundation, Munich, Germany.
Ann Maxillofac Surg. 2018 Jan-Jun;8(1):101-107. doi: 10.4103/ams.ams_122_18.
This article analyses published prior article regarding the questions: is the study setup correct (true) and if comparable cases are evaluated for the compared methods. Futhermore the content, the pictures, the tables, the graphs and the pictures legends of the article and statistics are analysed for truth, relevance and applicability. We investigate furthermore if this article addresses all relevant questions regarding bias, the study groups, the evaluation of the outcomes and the evaluation of patient parameters such as burden of the treatment. As a result of the analysis, we state that the analysed article is misleading and it does not provide valuable information regarding decision making for other healthcare professionals in the dental implant field.
研究设置是否正确(真实),以及所比较的方法是否对可比病例进行了评估。此外,还对文章的内容、图片、表格、图表、图片说明及统计数据进行了真实性、相关性和适用性分析。我们还研究了本文是否解决了所有与偏倚、研究组、结果评估以及患者参数评估(如治疗负担)相关的问题。分析结果表明,所分析的文章具有误导性,并且未为牙科种植领域的其他医疗保健专业人员提供有关决策的有价值信息。