Pouwels Sjaak, Stepaniak Pieter S, Buise Marc P, Bouwman R Arthur, Nienhuijs Simon W
1Department of Surgery, Catharina Hospital, Michelangelolaan 2, P.O. Box 1350, 5602 ZA Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
2Department of Epidemiology, CAPHRI Research School, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Indian J Surg. 2018 Jun;80(3):245-251. doi: 10.1007/s12262-016-1560-4. Epub 2016 Oct 19.
Quality of recovery could be influenced positively if there is less postoperative sore throat (POST). Eating a popsicle might attenuate this sore throat. Especially for bariatric surgery, early recovery is important. Adding popsicles to the postoperative protocol could be beneficial. Our hypothesis is that offering a popsicle in the recovery room to patients after bariatric surgery will decrease POST and will increase quality of postoperative recovery. Patients undergoing elective bariatric surgery, between the 23 February 2015 and 3 April, were randomised to either the popsicle group or control group. Primary endpoint was the incidence of POST and secondly if a reduction in POST influences quality of recovery at the first day postoperative measured with the Bariatric Quality Of Recovery (BQoR) questionnaire. One hundred and thirty-three patients were assessed for eligibility. For the final analysis, 44 patients in the intervention and 65 in the control group were available. Eating a popsicle after bariatric surgery had no significant effect on the incidence of POST. Significant effects (in favour of the popsicle group) were seen in muscle pain score ( = 0.047) and sore mouth score ( = 0.012). Popsicle intragroup analysis revealed that eating the whole popsicle (compared to partially eating the popsicle) has positive effects on nausea ( = 0.059), feeling cold ( = 0.008), and mean total comfort score ( = 0.011). Of the patients who became nauseous and/or had to vomit because of the popsicle, = 4 had more severe pain ( = 0.04) and the mean pain score was higher ( = 0.09). The present study demonstrates that offering a popsicle early during recovery after bariatric surgery is feasible without adverse effects, although eating popsicle did not reduce postoperative sore throat. There are possible beneficial effects, such as reduced muscle pains and less sore mouth, that may enhance the quality of recovery. More research is necessary to further substantiate the effect of eating popsicles on the quality of recovery in this patient population.
Registration number: NTR4943 (http://www.trialregister.nl).
如果术后咽痛(POST)较少,恢复质量可能会受到积极影响。吃一根冰棒可能会减轻这种咽痛。特别是对于减肥手术,早期恢复很重要。在术后护理方案中增加冰棒可能有益。我们的假设是,在减肥手术后的恢复室为患者提供一根冰棒将减少POST,并将提高术后恢复质量。2015年2月23日至4月3日期间接受择期减肥手术的患者被随机分为冰棒组或对照组。主要终点是POST的发生率,其次是POST的降低是否会影响术后第一天用减肥恢复质量(BQoR)问卷测量的恢复质量。评估了133名患者的 eligibility。最终分析时,干预组有44名患者,对照组有65名患者。减肥手术后吃冰棒对POST的发生率没有显著影响。在肌肉疼痛评分(P = 0.047)和口腔疼痛评分(P = 0.012)方面观察到显著效果(有利于冰棒组)。冰棒组内分析显示,吃完整根冰棒(与部分吃冰棒相比)对恶心(P = 0.059)、感觉寒冷(P = 0.008)和平均总舒适度评分(P = 0.011)有积极影响。因冰棒而出现恶心和/或呕吐的患者中,4名疼痛更严重(P = 0.04),平均疼痛评分更高(P = 0.09)。本研究表明,减肥手术后在恢复早期提供冰棒是可行的,且无不良影响,尽管吃冰棒并未减轻术后咽痛。可能有有益效果,如减轻肌肉疼痛和减少口腔疼痛,这可能会提高恢复质量。需要更多研究来进一步证实吃冰棒对该患者群体恢复质量的影响。
注册号:NTR4943(http://www.trialregister.nl)。